Chisau sifu vs sifu
Top Comments
All Comments (158)
-
@sai18kit You still dont understand.
Its the skill of the practitioner, NOT the practice itself.
-
@gambleyourhealth Tmr I am going to create an art, and you will have to use that art to beat other arts. Since you are such a good martial artist, I guess you can fix the art I created no matter how flawed it is? There was a person who created an martial art. A bad person will create a bad art. A better one create better art. Make sense?
-
@sai18kit the thing is, anyone is beatable by anything.
Its how good the artist is, not the art itself.
A Good WC guy will beat a BJJ guy thats only average.
A good TKD guy will beat a WC guy that is only average.
etc etc etc for all the arts.
A good boxer will kick another martial artists ass if that guy is only average in his art.
The artist, not the art.
-
@gambleyourhealth I might be beatable by a BJJ, but I was saying most of the tricks he showed me was so instinctively and quickly dismantled by me. I didn't even have to think. He just couldn't get me.
-
@sai18kit David Peterson learned it in HK from Wong Shun Leung (Bruce Lee's ACTUAL teacher)
As for BJJ - UFC is under rules, on the street it happens quite differently. There is a reason CMA's lose in a UFC setting.
I live in Australia.
"I wonder if u really understand WC? "
From some of your comments im wondering if YOU really understand Wing Chun. There is no unbeatable art. Its the Artist, not the Art that makes the difference.
BL knew this, thats why he developed JKD from WC.
-
@gambleyourhealth Where are you? If u are in Toronto we can meet. Well I have seen people who have 10+ WC but they would do better in boxing. Cuz they basically are doing amateur boxing using WC forms, but not real WC u know what I mean?
-
@gambleyourhealth Or maybe I haven't seen a good BJJ yet since I only defeated one? But still when I watched UFC, I see how they applied their forces in a wasteful way, from WC perspective. I always wonder if they would easily win if they only know WC well, when doing their UFC BJJ stuff.
-
@gambleyourhealth No offense, but I dont know David Peterson as I learned it from HK, and I see that many people with so many years of WC are still not good. They would do better in boxing, MT, even BJJ as they are so easy to learn with your eyes. What you see is what u get in those arts. But WC the subtle and how u use forces have to be learned abstractly. I wonder if u really understand WC?
-
@sai18kit As well as David Peterson I have also trained with other notable instructors. I have been training various martial arts for a long time. 10 years WC, 7 years BJJ, 9 years FMA.
-
@sai18kit and if you think BJJ is unskilled then you have only been against an unskilled BJJ practitioner. Fact is that if a skilled BJJ exponent gets a hold of you, its all over.
In the "eyes" of a wing chun sifu, (it's not the eyes, it's the hand that has "eyes", muscle memory) the opponent is full of opening and weakspots, by rolling hands in the exact right timing and posture, we are shifting our weakspot and opening to where the opponent can't hit, while automatically detecting if the opponent has any opening.
If we fight a non-wing chun guy, one or two rolling is usually enough to shift our opening and find his. One he get hit he's finish
sai18kit 2 years ago 19
greenarrow88 you are so mistaken... check gracie samual kwok seminar on you tube....it is in the cage has been for over 10 years...so easy to just watch and put ppl down..good example of chi sau non competitive but testing each other with no ego which a lot of ppl on here have!!!! big ego,s
deadlee27 2 years ago 6