Reinecke Flute Concerto Dmaj, 1st mvt, Galway
Uploader Comments (lolcow)
Top Comments
-
this is amazing. His tone is breathtaking...
All Comments (19)
-
@fairyrose444 My copy has a B, but a c does sound better.
-
Such a beautiful concerto! Learning it atm for an audition and recital
-
@MahoRoulete Shhh....he may find this and come a' trollin.
-
wow the first galway video i've seen that Rexicano HASNT criticized.
-
@fairyrose444 there are two version of this concert and many notes are different.. at 2.31 you can play C or B. Is the same. Reinecke wrote two version: one is from the flute's solo part, the second is from the orchestral score.
Breitkopf & Hartel has recently published a new edition of this concert thanks the help of german flutist Henrik Wiese.
-
@fairyrose444 that happens to mercadante concerto too if you notice carefully , there are two different versions. Mine has C but you can also find it with B.
-
@aaltobartok you have some serious problems lol
-
I'm no flautist, but I've just got to say this: There couldn't be a more perfect Romantic-style concerto for James Galway's style and sound!
(I'm afraid I can't and wouldn't want to join in the extremely technical discussions I see here, sorry.)
-
@aaltobartok i'm sorry but who the f**k are you to judge? a member of a school orchestra? lol ok
Now I am NOT criticizing him, but at 2:31 he plays a different note than what my part says (he plays a C instead of a B). Does he have a different edition or is it a wrong note?
fairyrose444 2 years ago
my edition Breitkopf & Hartel is a C... its correct to me...
lolcow 2 years ago
anyway, that part definitely is a C, cos that is an a minor arpeggio. its would sound wierd if it went E A B A G E G... its surely E A C A G E G
lolcow 2 years ago 3