Review of Middle Eastern Instruments with Focus on Afghanistan
Loading...
1,037
Loading...
Uploader Comments (LaurenL90)
see all
All Comments (11)
-
Please read the books of John Baily Mark Slobin and Hiromi Sakata carefully, you will find that the real afghan instruments look different. As I said before, many instruments have the same name but look different in different countries.
-
Say this guy something. he thinks he knows about Afghan music, and he doesn't!
-
Robabnawaz knows plays afghan music, ask him.
-
Robabnawaz, the guy from the bottom of this page have all the afghan instruments and can play them all.
See his videos and ask him about the instruments!
Loading...
These are deffenetly not afghan Instruments!
arkhatych 1 year ago
@arkhatych Some things may be mislabeled, but the instruments as listed in the comments section are certainly to be found in Afghanistan. Refer to the authors John Bailey, Mark Slobin, or Hiromi Sakata if you care to do more research on the subject.
LaurenL90 1 year ago
Dambura for example is uzbek instrument!
arkhatych 1 year ago
@arkhatych Yes but it is played in Northern Afghanistan. I meant to display all instruments that are commonly played in any part of Afghanistan, regardless of their origin.
LaurenL90 1 year ago
Afghan instruments are Pashtun, Tadjik or Aimaq/Hazara instruments! Uzbek or pamir instruments are not Afghan
arkhatych 1 year ago
@arkhatych I based this video on the research done by the three PhD's listed above. If you want to argue with people who have dedicated their lives to researching Afghan music in all its manifestations, be my guest. I have little more to say on the subject. Thank you for your interest.
LaurenL90 1 year ago