Brian McFadden wants to rejoin Westlife - but band are not interested The Sun Showbiz Bizarre

here is some of what shane have said
SHANE FILAN said: "I don't think it's even remotely interesting if Brian came back.
"Brian left because he didn't like being in the band. It wasn't because we fell out.
"For us as a band, we never split up. We've kept going and are very happy."
He added: "If another person came in it would be like re-starting a new band.
"I don't know how it would work. ROBBIE WILLIAMS coming back to Take That was a big announcement.
"He's the biggest male solo performer of the past 20 years.
"You can't compare it."

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• westlife
• will
• not
• take
• brian
• back

[thhorrorthepain]

well...Brian made a mistake of leaving the band. he shouldn't have left in the first place.

[Tvjunkieful12]

As much as I think it should be up to the remaining 4 guys in Westlife to decide wether or not they should have Brian back, I think to publicly dismiss him like this is in poor taste. Sorry, Shane, you got a great voice - but you don`t appear to be much of a diplomat. Even for publicity reasons this question should have been unanswered - opening up for speculations of him returning for the goodbye tour. He was there in the start - so wouldn`t it be appropriate he was there when it finished?

[HenryHins]

4 is better than 5 , he wanna be back was just because he isn't famous

[Bestpogi29]

sometimes people done crazy things because they are not perfect. sometimes they are make mistakes, but God always forgive the mistakes of what people done. because God Love us.

as i heard that the reason why mcfadden left westlife is beacause he want's to be a solo performer especially of her girlfriend . "Friends stays Together Wins Together Happy Together"

[Bestpogi29]

PLSSSSS. FORGIVE BRYAN GIVE HIM 1 MORE LAST CHANCE BECAUSE WESTLIFE WILL NEVER EVER BE WESTLIFE IF ONE OF THE PART,PIECE OF IT GONE.................WEST LIFE IS THE BEST BAND!! AND I WANT TO SEE NEW MUSIC ALBULMS ,VIDEOS WITH 5 MEMBER OF WESTLIFE

[TheMhew]

@KristongHari hahaha 1st time i heard, I think the same.. he said like Take That's going to be massive again because of Robbie while Brian was difference Lol anyway no Westlife anymore ..so sad

[ydujEMB]

WESTLIFE is FOREVER.. the fact that Brian leaves the band how many years, i guess if he wants to come back they will appreciate him again as one of the singers in westlife.. but now they are all splitting up, i wish they will be friends forever..ALWAYS.. :)

[KingJarett]

anyway..i guess it's over! The fact now is they are all splitting up!

[dark69angle]

leaving for a girl is not a good choice..