Jan and Dean - Surf City (Live 1963)
Uploader Comments (John1948SIxC)
Top Comments
-
Jan & Dean belong in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.
They had many hits, fans and helped to create sounds that were legendary.
J&D and the Beach Boys created the California surf sound that helped to define the 1960's.
I shake my head at some of the acts already in the Hall.
Many did not do half of what Jan & Dean did.
George Vreeland Hill
-
Well there is a reason AC/DC joked about with regard to their own induction..calling it the "hall of lame"
All Comments (35)
-
@John1948SIxC : I always thought the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame was based in Cleveland, OH.
-
I agree with both arcamadeus and GeorgeVreelandhill, the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame is a joke! One example, the Flamingos had to wait for induction when other less than deserving were admitted. J&D should without a doubt be there.
-
Love these guys but even for the scene back then they were soooo cheesy. I've seen them live and really enjoyed their concerts..... but, come on, two guys and a microphone and layers of harmony parts without a band... clearly lip synch, and all about aesthetics. Tony Dow would have made a neat addition to the band!
-
Uh Oh..."and when I get to Surf City, I'll be shootin' the curl, and all you got to do is just wink your eye...." THIS IS a live recording, all right. Great to see these guys again though!
-
@John1948SIxC jAN was a musicail genious to the day he died, still worked on his craft, it just took him longer to conplete due to his disabilities, but speed dosent make you a genious, the final product tells the story. Jan isnt just a favorite singer to me, he is my heroe and role model, he never gave up. I was born with multi disabilities and when I have a hard day I know I can make it thru vecause Jan did. Greene makes it sound like Jan DIED iApr. 12, 1966 not March 26, 2004. POOH ON HIM
-
@John1948SIxC So far as I know there is no in deph biography on Jan or Dean. Jan was working on an autobiograpthy , with the help of a writter when he died. I havent heard if the project was ever conpleted or published, last I heard they were tracking down documentation. There is a book called DEAD MAN S CURVE AND BACK by MARK PASSMORE. There is a lot the writter misses the mark on, IMO
-
@rockinrobintweets @OnTheWatch Good discussion guys. It does make me want to read the Greene book. rockinrobin do you know of any biographies that you can recommend. I think we can agree that Jan and Dean led way for the California sound and were a huge influence on the Beach Boys. There was some real genius there!
-
@OnTheWatch Did Bob Greene play with the band in Ca. and what would be loccail areas to where Jan lived. If so, he should have SEEN Gertie , Jan s wife as she was there LOTS of times, to many pictures to dispute it. I didnt say Jan was perfact I saied he wasnt the broken sad lonely man with no life, other then the stage and I still say it. And Greene made it almost all pre accident verus post accident Jan, he didnt see JAN as a person or man so I cant like Greene or the book
-
@rockinrobintweets Thanks for your reply, your opinion is noted. However, I respectfully disagree with your premise. Greene is a veteran reporter, let's assume he’s one without an axe to grind with Jan Berry. What he wrote in Surf City is what he observed on the tours. I didn't get any sense the book was a hatchet job. Jan's determination re-learning lyrics again and again+Jan being difficult - we're all like that, it's human. Was Jan a good guy? No doubt. Was he a pain sometimes? Probably.
Rock and Roll Hall of Fame has become a sick joke!
arcamadeus 7 months ago
@arcamadeus It has never been much of anything. It is just a group of Detroit people who wanted to start a tourist attraction. There is no rhyme nor reason to any of their decisions.
John1948SIxC 7 months ago