Documentary preview: "Bartitsu - the Lost Martial Art of Sherlock Holmes"
Uploader Comments (BartitsuSociety)
Top Comments
-
Yes. Because we all know Mua Thai with BJJ is the only and best style of martial arts.
What about a boxing and pankration combo?
Savate and Russian sambo?
Judo and kickboxing?
There's a lot of styles that will get you in basically the same place. Just because BJJ and MT schools are the most common in the U.S. and in UFC, it doesn't mean that it is automatically the way and the only way to effectively fight.
-
Raposamandinga, yes, of course; most people involved in reviving Bartitsu have backgrounds in other historical martial arts reconstruction, including work with the Flos Duellatorum. Likewise, many martial arts from different periods and cultures have combined unarmed striking and grappling with weapon training.
The significance of Bartitsu in that sense is that it was the first method to deliberately blend Asian and European self defence arts into a more-or-less cohesive system.
Video Responses
All Comments (85)
-
@aethelwyn666 - Barton-Wright spent three years living in Japan, between 1895-98. He studied at the Shinden Fudo Ryu jujitsu dojo of sensei Terajima Kuniichiro in Kobe, and also with Professor Jigoro Kano (Kodokan Judo). Barton-Wright spoke Japanese and pioneered the teaching of Japanese martial arts in the Western world.
-
Mr Barton was a guy finding very clever to put his name in front of a japanese sounding suffix like "tsu" to make it sound cool. Doesn't mean he actually knew anything about japanese. It was just cool at the time to do asian sports, it was new !
-
Lolz. Sherlock Holmes is a fictional character.
-
Time to dig up some instructional videos or something.
-
Well it's a good thing Sherlock Holmes was said to use Baritsu! Which is about as fictional as he is, so this isn't any conspiracy :)
And where is the reference to canne de combat and savate ? It mainly originates from the french sports. And the guy just told himself he could mix a bit of asian stuff in it. And why didn't his club last long ? The guy gave his name to the sport mixing it with some asian suffix to make it sound cool. We should concentrate on making canne live ( because we are only 3000 peple practising it in France ) because it's dying here, Instead of reviving something that didn't work because it was useless.
aethelwyn666 2 weeks ago
@aethelwyn666 - this is a preview trailer for a full-length documentary. There are multiple shots (historical images and re-enactment footage) showing savate and the canne Vigny method in the trailer, and obviously both styles are discussed in greater depth in the documentary itself. No-one knows why the original Bartitsu Club didn't last. Historically, Bartitsu was composed of about 2/3 jujitsu and a remaining 1/3 combination of English boxing and Pierre Vigny's system.
BartitsuSociety 2 weeks ago
IN Italy that would be called simply "Scrimia" or "NOva Scrimia"; it comes from a tradition of hand by hand and armed style of close combat with several sources like Flos Liberorum and Duellatorum with newer integrations of Carmine Boxing and XVIII and XIX centuries well known styles.
NOthing new except for the obviously well working movie's battage of advertisement.
Spartacus74 2 months ago
@Spartacus74 - as it happens, members of Nova Scrimia performed Bartitsu-style stick fighting demonstrations for this documentary.
There are numerous modern revivals of historical martial arts systems, each one representing, as well as they can, the flavour and detail of the originals.
BartitsuSociety 2 months ago