Haley Reinhart - I Who Have Nothing (BEST PERFORMANCE?) - American Idol 5/11/11 SHOW REVIEW!

American Idol season 10 (2011) top 4 performances episode REVIEW for May 11th, 2011. (5/11/11) THIS IS A REVIEW, with no show footage included.
The top 4 contestants sung two songs each tonight. One song was anything that inspired them, and the other song was from the works of Lieber and Stoller. Haley Reinhart was the best contestant tonight for the third week in a row! (In my opinion, of course.) She first sung "Earth Song", and I thought it was great, despite the judges tearing her apart. Haley later performed "I Who Have Nothing." BEST VOCAL IN MONTHS, FANTASTIC!

Lady Gaga mentored the contestants for the second round of songs.
Her credibility instantly fell to shreds after dressing like a buffoon.
As for my prediction of elimination tomorrow, I would say Scotty.
However, I feel that nobody is safe.

PERFORMANCE LIST:
James Durbin -- "Don't Stop Believing" by Journey
Haley Reinhart -- "Earthsong" by Michael Jackson
Scotty McCreery -- "Where Were You When The World Stopped Turning" by Alan Jackson
Lauren Alaina -- "Anyway" by Martina McBride
Haley Reinhart -- "I Who Have Nothing" by Ben E. King
Scotty McCreery -- "Young Blood" by The Coasters
Lauren Alaina -- "Trouble" by Elvis Presley
James Durbin "Love Potion #9″ by The Clovers

Tell me your favorite performance/least favorite performance/prediction for elimination in a comment. Rate thumbs up and subscribe if you like my videos.
Also, Jordin Sparks is confirmed for tomorrow night, singing "I Am Woman."
Steven Tyler is premiering a new music video. I think somebody else was going to perform but I can't for the life of me remember who it is.

Performance list courtesy of MJ's Big Blog:
http://mjsbigblog.com/

Main channel, which you're watching this video on now:
http://www.youtube.com/user/zebracrunk

Side channel, for more American Idol videos:
http://www.youtube.com/user/kama

Twitter, please follow me for what I think are hilarious tweets:
http://twitter.com/zebracrunk


Attention Freemantle Media:
This video is a review that I created to critique an episode of American Idol. My video has a custom thumbnail that is an enabled feature for YouTube partners. While there are pictures from American Idol, they are photos that I modified in Adobe Photoshop. This is legal under fair use law. My thumbnail is so different from any actual video that it does not look like your content at all. This custom photo is for representative purposes only. I own everything used in this video, so if you have any questions, shoot me an email at zebracrunk (at) gmail (dot) com. Thank you for reading.

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• American
• Idol
• Top
• Four
• 2011
• Season
• 10
• May
• 11th
• Show
• Review
• Scotty
• McCreery
• James
• Durbin
• Lauren
• Alaina
• Haley
• Reinhart
• Who
• Have
• Nothing
• Earth
• Song
• Lady
• Gaga
• Eliminated

[KaliBentleydotcom]

nerd



[zebracrunk]

@KaliBentleydotcom Why am I not surprised that you're 14 years old?

[zebracrunk]

@emcee2k11 If you watched more than 30 seconds of my video you would hear me making fun of myself. Thanks for the self esteem boost though, you're very kind.

[lklove56]

You talked way to much great info .....but would like to hear songs

[prinscstasneem]

@Beatlezgurly you know that your not getting thumbs up for that.

[halabrdave]

The difference between Haley and the rest is loud and clear. If anyone thinks Scotty is better, sorry that person is just retarded. He should have been in the bottom 3 way more times than Haley. He never was, he had million of girls voting for him 2000 times each. And why the fuck people stopped voting for Haley because of her attitude?! She always get trashed and now she get trashed because she talked back. She can't please everybody, that woud make her bland and she isn't... Scotty sucks.

[hellokitty4371]

you move your head tuh much ...

[LookingAtYouFool]

@ReneeLGlenney

“Haley is so down to earth,” school choir director and band director Brian Logan told the Daily Herald . “There is not a diva bone in her body. She has true grace....I never sense from her anything but, 'How can I be part of this? How can I learn?'… If she was a diva, we wouldn't have had her sing with us. We have a chill kind of atmosphere."

[liddy722]

STFU HALEY SUCK LAUREN IS BETTER AND POINT WHY LAURENS GUNNA BE FAMOUS NOT HALEY NOHEART

OR SOUL

[liddy722]

ok, do your self a favor , CUT YOUR HAIR , GET CONTACTS , STOP JUDGING POEPLE LOOK IN THE MIRROR, AND MY RATE IS A BIG ASS THUMBBS DOWN, WE DONT LOVE HEARING WHAT U THINK SO BYE

[Beatlezgurly]

@findunk Not critisising. Its a word called an OPINION. you wouldnt understand.

[robertospd1]

he talked to much i got bored sorry i thought you were going to show hayley's performance