Eva Brandys Performing Bach Prelude in C Minor B 847
Loading...
Link to this comment:
Top Comments
All Comments (250)
-
it is not about interpretation - dislikes are because half of the time she cannot get both hands together! that, I am sure, WAS Bach's original intention.
-
Eva, always cooking...
Great, as usual.
-
I love this interpretation of this piece and the paying. Fantastic. The reason why it has taken so many negatives is because she's playing it similarly to Glenn Gould -- whom a lot of musicians and people in the music world can't stand, and who see him as a a bit of a gimmick. Just sayin ... in case one was trying to figure out the reason why all the neg votes.
-
As there're many arrangements for this piece - (Bach never indicated anything more than the notes, so they're usually adapted to what the arrangers interpret it as). You can interpret it however you want without having uneducated criticism all over you. It's like disagreeing her opinion(interpretation) that pretty much doesn't have a right nor wrong. The tempo was right, goes along with my arrangement. Well done, liked the presto part.
-
why so many dislikes? this is pretty bitchin I think, but then again I dont know much about what im talkin about
-
*every video of this song there's some huge argument about tempo in the comments*
-
@Gabrielicus Encuentro errado el concepto de que Gould interpreta bien a Bach. Glenn Gould interpreta bien a Glenn Gould, asi de simple. Fue un gran pianista, y tambien me gusta, pues es una forma un poco original de tocar a Bach, pero eso no quiere decir que interprete bien a Bach, es por eso que encuentro su interpretación de este preludio particularmente errada, por no decir espantosa. Para mi el mejor en este Preludio y Fuga es Sviatoslav Richter.
-
@ifailatediting Czerny's edition has 144, it's an editorial addition. Beethoven was the first major composer to use Metronome indications. Maezel's Metronome wasn't "invented" (Maezel ripped off Winkel's Chronometer) until 94 years after J S Bach assembled the 1st book of the WTC and 66 years after his death. Four different Musicologists have written on the subject of Baroque time signatures as Tempo indication,
2:59J.S.Bach - Prelude and Fugue no.2 in C minor, W...by emg98167,363 views
- 5:18Prelude and Fugue No. 1 in C major, BWV 846, fr...by henripche553,489 views
- 3:02Johann Sebastian BACH: Prelude No. 1, C Major, ...by cubusdk81,712 views
- 4:03Valentina Lisitsa.Chopin Nocturne E Flat Major ...by proektmedia14,678 views
- 1:17Bach BWV 847 Prelude c minorby sspect43,127 views
- 3:39Popular New Wedding Song - Dreams Come True a/k...by jdia1943458,672 views
- 13:25The madness of genius Glenn Gould (4)by 3parsifal49,309 views
- 2:46Girl play piano with no finger on one handby georgeju19742,910,185 views
- 2:32J.S. Bach - Praeludium 1 (C-Dur)by MrRodneyMcKay15,409 views
- 1:59Bach - Prelude in C Minor BWV 999by DecafCappuccino3,881 views
- 3:28The Greatest Bass Solo Everby Forkplus1577,697 views
- 1:37Bach Little Prelude in C Minorby RespectedEnt43,647 views
- 5:24Prelude and Fugue No. 2 in C minor, BWV 871, fr...by henripche29,219 views
- 4:35Keith Jarrett plays Bach's Prelude and Fugue in...by PiotrekChrobot46,985 views
- 2:47Watch this and see why Martha Argerich is the g...by lawrencehei335,281 views
- 3:393-year-old Hiyori plays pianoby hiyorinmamy241,104 views
- 2:22Ton Koopman performs Bachby NaxosUSA7,970 views
- 2:33pianist (5 year old Japanese girl):Bach Gigueby paddler164,955,054 views
- 2:14Bach Cello Suite No. 1 Piano Versionby fendraki8,418 views
@frekijsimpson I can't stand your type of people. Just because she interprets it differently from the narrow opinion you have formed, you think that means she can't play. OPEN YOUR MIND!!! People are different.
And personally, I quite liked her playing, I don't see how you can not.
punkypenguin321 9 months ago 17
77 people dont play piano
garrittpwl 3 months ago 7