Angela Hewitt : Bach Performance on the Piano, Excerpt 1
Uploader Comments (mariandelochs)
Top Comments
-
Angela Hewitt is a genius...her Bach has colour, personality and a most appealing stylishness, never weighted down by scholarship or erudition, though there is enough scholarship for the most fanatical of musicologists. To me her Bach playing has what her fellow Canadian Glenn Gould's lacked, and I put her with Edwin Fischer and Rosalyn Tureck as one of the alltime great Bach pianists.
-
She explains it so well, and it really makes you want to play it more... She makes the music sound rich and expressive...
All Comments (43)
-
Wow!
-
that's one of the worst interpretations of the Bach i ever heard. the thing that keep me pressing the Unlike button is our common love for Bach. regarding her criticism of harpsichord i only know that i have listened some of Landowska interpretations are so emotionally that made me cried ... so something must be wrong with her theory.
-
@version191 I agree with in some ways but there is a good reason why many people love Hewitt's playing. It is not necessarily the best by any means but she portrays a side of Bach that makes her interpretation appealing in some manner.
-
That harpsichord sounds like a typewriter.
-
@HerlockSholmes123 Is this like a "massive bullshite" comment? Gould's interpretation of Bach is appealing if you like your Bach played like a high-speed train on its last run of the day. Sometimes, I like it that way, too. Other times, I like it a bit more ... refined and thoughtful. Gould's idiosyncratic style and interpretations are not the be-all and end-all of Bach.
-
Maybe, she's "opinionated" because she has spent decades studying and playing Bach and his contemporaries. I dunno ... does a world expert and world-class pianist with that kind of commitment have a right to be "opinionated"? Hmm, tough one. Well, not really.
-
Forget about the manuals... on the harpsichord, the string is plucked a second time when you take the note off, which gives a whole new dimension to articulation. This is one of the reasons why applying harpsichord articulation to the piano mostly doesn't work out so well... then, the piano can't make such "crisp" arpeggios as the harpsichord, it doesn't "rawk" so hard in up-tempo pieces, etc. - so you lose a lot by playing Baroque on the piano, but, of course, you gain a lot, as well ;)
-
I share this view on some pieces, like the 1st movement of the 6th Brandenburg concerto (everyone aside from Goebel makes me wanna "sleep"), but I don't mind with this invention ;)
-
Agree with this reply completely.
-
nice playing, well shaped, but why try to juxtapose piano against harpsichord when it's a case of apples and oranges. If Bach wrote for the harpsichord that's what he knew. How do we know what he would have felt about the modern day piano and if he would have been happy with today's Fazioli, Yamaha, Steinway, etc. Let's let the great harpsichords keep playing Bach, and the pianists do the same without value judgments.
shes pretty opinionated about what the "right" way to play bach is. I think she makes the music dull and meandering. IMO bach sounds best rhythmically straight. Any amount of rubato or whimsy and I want to fall asleep. I like the way she plays 20thc music, though
version191 5 months ago
@version191
As are you in your opinions. Like so many others. No wishy-washiness here, which I like.
mariandelochs 5 months ago
Thank you for this very instructive video! VERY proud of our Canadian pianist!!!
OldRabit 1 year ago 4
Yes, I love Angela Hewitt's very lucid teaching videos - besides her exquisite Bach recordings!
mariandelochs 1 year ago 2