Pinky~ Elton John cover by David Scott Crawford
Uploader Comments (louvregroove)
Video Responses
All Comments (13)
-
The opening was rather like 'Ticking' :D!
-
Great song...Songs like these always make me wonder what happened to Elton John's writing ability in the last 20 years.
-
Check out L10Johnathan's version, WOW!
-
Thanks for your invite... no worries, there already! Merry Christmas and best wishes for a good 2K9
-
Nigel: You make valid points here, so I'll take what I can use from you comments and leave the rest.
In my own defense,I am quite pleased with this performance.The arrangment on 'Caribou' has a lot of instrumentation on it,so the piano performance is by neccessity 'sparser'. BTW,David Hentshel,who played synth on EJ's version mixed & played on my CD 'Belle Epoque'. I will probably re-record this anyway as one of the keys was buzzing. Are you a musician or merely a critic? Post your own version.
-
I can't agree w/the majority of the people in here about your musical talent. What I find is that the melodic vocal phrasing is missing and the piano isn't as sparce as the original song. What all musicians NEED AND MUST realize is that not only is it important to know when to play, it's just important to know when NOT to play. This performance finds me feeling that this musician is trying to get this song over as quickly as possible while I find myself wishing the original would never end!
A great arrangement! I have had a "stab" at this song, but mine is not a patch on yours. You're a really great player and have done an excellent job on this song.
tonemcs 1 year ago
@tonemcs Thanks for the very kind comment. Much appreciated. Thanks alo for subscribing! DSC
louvregroove 1 year ago
this song shows the sheer songwriting genius of Elton John (& Bernie Taupin)...it's deceptively easy yet stunning in it's effect...one of his greatest songs ever...good job dude...
mineheadX1 3 years ago
mineheadX1...thanks for the kind comment. I'd like to invite you to subscribe to my channel for future posts!
louvregroove 3 years ago
Excellent David, love your version, dare I say it, it is funkier than E.J.'s own!
gail1964 3 years ago
gail1964....I think I forgot to invite you to subscribe to my channel, and again, thanks for the kind comment!
louvregroove 3 years ago