Clay Shirky: Are Lolcats a Sign of Human Progress?
Top Comments
Video Responses
All Comments (65)
-
Poo poo
-
@oninoshiko Wikipedia defacement is counter-progress because it removing an aspect of progress. Now creating a wiki page about non-sense, is progress. Lorenzo Von Matterhorn is a great illustration of that.
As for propaganda, it is progress, because now you are creating images, and altering thoughts. Yet, you've progressed because you've added to someone's spectrum of knowledge and have deepened the information they can draw from. So it is progressive, but it is destructive progress.
-
Hey look the first time I've wanted to pay for content in years.
-
pjuny hoomian i haz cheezburger
- no progres....
-
i CAN has human progress
-
Mr. Shirky makes the intrinsic assumption that "involvement" is better then not being involved. I think this assumption is not a safe one. Every "wikipedia defacement" is involvement, is that progress? When hate groups post their propaganda, that is "involvement," but is is progress?
-
@jacobbocanegra yea but everyone likes cats with funny messages.
-
@LegendaryDie It's always like this, every other category is at least 100 times as much.
-
@iTzEvrywhere It might be for today only, which, depending on the timezone YouTube uses, may have been reset only a few hours ago. Not really sure how it works.
can i haz human progres?
ShaedeReshka 1 year ago 83
@Phelan666
did you just post that on the 'net with your computer, powered by electricity in your centrally heated home, at an age you would never have reached a few decades ago? Did you risk your life to hunt your lunch?
Although I do question the value of that progress when the level of ignorance you possess is tolerated.
As for man made illusions; I know your sphincter must feel stretched out now but maybe the sky daddy will help you huh?
1HumanKind 1 year ago 27