Uploader Comments (superfliproductions)
Top Comments
-
i'll be honest. Birdy's cover of this song is far better :)
-
Thank-you Cherry Ghost for this touching song... THIS is Music... and thank-you "superfliproductions" for posting this wonderful words...
All Comments (37)
-
@MeganRR I think you've misinterpreted the comment. You can sing a song as beautifully as Birdy, you can connect to it for sure, this song brings tears to my eyes and fills my heart with sorrow, but you can never feel it truly because it's not yours, it's just an interpretation. This song belongs to Simon, it's imprinted with his life, his hope, his fears and the same can be said for all art. An artist creates for themselves, it's a piece of them, not us, and I think we can often forget that.
-
@Neima521 She does lay down a great vocal, and she is a very talented young lady, but there is no way that she could sing it true to the meaning, she can't understand it completely because she didn't experience what led to it's creation. If you've ever written something you'd know what I mean.
-
@blackarawak83 Really? I find that Birdy's version sounds a lot more emotional. I think she sung it true to the meaning. Not that the Cherry Ghost's isn't amazing, I just find Birdy's a lot more emotional.
-
Guys I made a cover of this song if you have a minute to check out my channel, thanks :)
-
i adore both versions, i honestly couldn't choose between them! wonderful song.
-
@po72644 I think it's open to interpretation. Calling Birdy's cover "better" is just one side of the opinions. Personally I prefer the original, but that's me. Neither is right or wrong, neither version is "better"
-
wth all u talkin about birdy cover?here is cherry ghost so write ur opinion in her cover.thumbs up for cherry ghost.
-
@Auri489 I think that's ridiculous. So no one can appreciate anything unless they wrote it themselves. All those people so moved by Shakespeare or poetry or cry at concerts because they're having the time of their life? Are they just full of shit? C'mon man. People connect. That's what we do.
-
Check out the slideshow and JESS’ VERSION of this song at lawguags1
-
i hate birdys version but love this!!!
yeah its alright but i do agree it could have been a little faster
superfliproductions 2 years ago 3