700+ foot Baseball Trebuchet
Loading...
11,722
Loading...
NOTICE
This video contains an audio track that has not been authorized by WMG. The audio has been disabled. More about copyright
Uploader Comments (ldvance01)
see all
All Comments (66)
-
@ldvance01 Thanks for you help, Mr. Vance. I'll be sure to tell you the results of the competition.
-
@ldvance01 i will send you a message
Loading...
You see, I've this school project that you're only supposed to throw the ball a measly fifteen feet (That's where the target is).
Any suggestions from your most humblest proffesional opinion?
tgmeier36 1 month ago
@tgmeier36 : if your contest is for accuracy, use a simple single arm pendulum style treb. Keeping things as simple as possible is a sound engineering principle. If there are other considerations in your contest (weight, height etc) let me know - the advice will change.
LDVance
ldvance01 1 month ago
@ldvance01: You see, it's only supposed to throw at a fifteen feet target... Ergo it's judged for accuracy, but it's also judge on efficency. now I'm no expert at tRebuchets, but, the greater the efficiency, the farther the projectile goes? Correct me if I'm wrong, please.
tgmeier36 1 month ago
@tgmeier36: Efficiency is measured as the energy of the projectile as it's released divided by the total energy available from the drop of the counterweight. My early MURLINS had 90% efficiency and shot 100 feet. My new treb has 42% efficiency but shoots 1100 feet. This is because the new treb has 110lb of counterweight and the old one had only 3 lb of CW.
If you need efficiency, build a Floating arm or MURLIN
ldvance01 1 month ago
Did you design this yourself?
If so, HOW IN THE WORLD?
tgmeier36 1 month ago
@tgmeier36 : I think I use the same basic method many of the innovative treb designers use (see First in Fright or Merlin). Insight to a possible interesting design is followed up with a lot of simulation analysis. In short, detailed mathematical modeling and the resulting optimization you can get from that make a big difference.
LDVance
ldvance01 1 month ago