Top Comments
All Comments (41)
-
I never imagined a woman singing this song, but if anybody could do it, it would be Judy Garland. Amazing. And there's a kind of fierce desperation about the end.
-
Judy is tremendous plowing through this great song with a fiery soulfulness that is electrifying...love how she nails it at the end and "Joey, Joey, Joey" is her classic...Bravo Judy, love you and RIP great lady...
-
@defundthewar if my mom was ill I would not have celebrated for the whole life as I do Lorna and Joey! for me they have exaggerated the reality in the book.
-
I think that Judy was a Good Mom. Liza said that her has a happy child. And Lorna and Joey in video or photo are happy with their mother. I think that Lorna living in the shadow of her mother.this is the problem for her. Judy was not perfect but I don't think the beat son! (sorry for my english)
-
I love everything about this song and her interpretation. She was the best.
-
@defundthewar how dare you
-
The song choice on this show was so canny and diverse. Imagine the incredible library it could have created of Judy's masterful renditions if it had run for "two or three or four or more" seasons!
-
I'll be the 1st to say our greatest 20th century male/female performers were Judy and Frank Sinatra. I've never questioned her talent. But when I read the usual folklore passing for truth, I say something. The silliest- that frumpy old Mrs. Gumm whored herself to advance Judy's career, when not busy scoring amphetamines to feed Judy, or Judy sounded the same in 1969 as she did at Carnegie Hall, and looked wonderful... either you respect and value the truth or you don't, it's that simple.
-
@defundthewar WOW you really dont sound like a Judy fan ever comment I read you are either calling her a liar or something else.. Every comment I read you find ways of bashing this woman's talent and her character..
-
@weightfeather1 Generally, if a story makes it into more than one biography with corroboration, it may be considered to have some credence. Since it's been a number of years since I read those bios, I'll go back to my local library and see if I can find sources to quote directly Then, it'll be up to the individual whether they choose to give the stories credence. That would be the most non-partial thing to do.



You know what...I love the effect caused by old black & white television recordings on Judy's gowns...It looks like her dress is wired with fairy lights and she is plugged into the mains...it's wonderful!...oh...and I've always loved this song too...
chunkylumps 3 years ago 8
BEAUTIFUL!. Judy is so magnificent
trueloveisnotreal 3 years ago 4