When Dorothy asked if she could have seen the product in New York it seems to me she should have gotten a no. How many haystacks are in Manhattan? (When Manhattanites say "New York" they do not mean the state, they mean the city.)
That "alive" thing is confusing,I don't know why I remember it from my kid days of playing word games.For example a tree is alive, but in this game it was NOT considered alive?Great point on the hay thing like wood is not alive. I guess I liked to argue these points alot as a kid(still do lol)but that just sticks in my brain about plants and such not considered to have life which well to me they do.Or maybe it was the whole "are they aware, sentient beings"Arrgh here I go again babblin' away :-)
Probably the logic of that alive answer is something like this: we use hay when it is cut, it has to be cut to be hay, so it is not alive. Pretty confusing stuff.
When Dorothy asked if she could have seen the product in New York it seems to me she should have gotten a no. How many haystacks are in Manhattan? (When Manhattanites say "New York" they do not mean the state, they mean the city.)
wmlfan9 2 years ago 2
Quite entertaining. Thanks very much.
13loomisst 2 years ago
Actually, hay is just grass that has been cut and dried. Not animal alive, but the cells were once.
TheLights045 2 years ago
The answer should have been yes. Because he asked if it had "ever" been alive. Animals aren't the only things that can be alive.
bhamdodger 2 years ago
That "alive" thing is confusing,I don't know why I remember it from my kid days of playing word games.For example a tree is alive, but in this game it was NOT considered alive?Great point on the hay thing like wood is not alive. I guess I liked to argue these points alot as a kid(still do lol)but that just sticks in my brain about plants and such not considered to have life which well to me they do.Or maybe it was the whole "are they aware, sentient beings"Arrgh here I go again babblin' away :-)
SueBeaWho 2 years ago
Hay, Hay, Hay, stick the needle into Bennett
XMLarry 2 years ago
Probably the logic of that alive answer is something like this: we use hay when it is cut, it has to be cut to be hay, so it is not alive. Pretty confusing stuff.
soulierinvestments 2 years ago
Mars. Hay has never been alive on Mars, therefore the answer is valid.
Senpumaru 2 years ago
Those interested in seeing this broadcast's mystery guest refer to What's My Line? NorbertR33 Elizabeth Ashley.
soulierinvestments 2 years ago
Dorothy is the best!
mam801 2 years ago