Pete Seeger and Bruce Springsteen - This Land is Your Land
Uploader Comments (musicinhistory)
Top Comments
-
Its wonderful that this is one of the very few times two of the "socialist" verses have been included. And that too at the president's inaugural concert. Even Arlo rarely sang them. However even here some lines were watered down. The original lines are "In the squares of the city, In the shadow of a steeple; By the relief office, I'd seen my people. As they stood there hungry, I stood there asking, Is this land made for you and me? "
-
Even though I am English I find this song both incredibly moving and incredibly powerful.
Wardy
All Comments (43)
-
long love Pete Seeger
-
I love Pete
-
A great big wall there,
Said private property,
But on the other side,
It didn't say nothing;
That side was made for you and me.
-
@WardyLion same here. it's just lovely.
-
As a foreign-born American who earned his US citizenship through military service in Iraq and Afghanistan, I find this song deeply touching. I'm slightly embarrassed to admit that it moves me to tears. This land *was* made for you and me. Sometimes we're so wrapped up in our own lives that we forget to be grateful for the simple things.
-
Vale and with deep respect for the following sacred names not mentioned during this celebration of disremembering: American Horse (Sioux) Black Elk (Lakota) Big Bear (Cree) Bigfoot (Lakota) Abel Bosum (Cree) Joseph Brant (Mohawk) Cochise (Apache) Choncape Chou-man-i-case Corn Planter Crazy Horse/Tashunkewitko (Lakota) Dan George Dull Knife (Cheyenne) Eagle og Delight Frank Fools Crow Gall (Hunkpapa Sioux)
-
Glenn Beck Is a mere freak of nature who'll be washed away by the tide from the oil spill which he endorses ....the big rich oil corporations such as BP....
-
Switching channels recently Glen Beck on FOX News had the gall to call this song a Socialist Song because of the Line about the No Trespassing Sign
-
but on the other side it didnt say nothing. that side was made for you and me
-
sitting here, thinking about the oil disaster in the gulf......makes me cry....they took it.
The many 1960's versions of this song seemed to have been "sanitized", not including all the verses heard here. I don't know if this was because Guthrie's manuscripts had not been published yet. I have only one version [besides Woody's] with all the verses from an '05 CD titled "Freedom: Special 20th Anniversary Collection" sung by various artists, including John McCutcheon, Willie Nelson & Tom Paxton, but I have read that Arlo Guthrie as well as Pete Seeger sing all of them as well.
toftmf 3 years ago
Yep, the more political verses with socialist overtones are often removed, which changes the whole complexion of the song. It's ironic that Woody Guthrie was responding to the nauseating patriotism of God Bless America but doctoring This Land probably turned it into something similar.
musicinhistory 3 years ago 4