Uploader Comments (Nocaro)
Top Comments
-
I was watching a movie about Sinatra and his music. One thing a person said was that people loved him for giving credit and not taking a lot for his own. You can see that it's true in this, when he sings all the people that sang this before. Also in his recording of "Hello Dolly" when he swaps a few words out to give props to Louis Armstrong.
All Comments (40)
-
Slow- Fox
-
@January2454 too late now their all dead now :P
-
@January2454 Armstrong does it for me. He's undeniable
-
drop the ad!!!!!!!
-
no better male singer than sinatra dear.
-
you must be joking - frank sinatra is the best male singer ever DEAR!!
-
The LP cut of this song is slightly different. It doesn't have the overdub at the end of the song, I have the LP and noticed the difference when it finally came to CD.
-
@January2454 Frank is mentioning Mr Darin while he is singing this song, in the middle of this song, however with all respect to Bobby the one sang by Dean was phenomenal too
-
I love Darins version best!! No one can sing it like he can!
This song is owned by Bobby Darin and nobody else can touch it. Sinatra and everybody else (living and dead) should just leave it alone. Sinatra has other great songs, but his version of this one just sounds anemic. Go listen to Darin do it.
January2454 3 months ago
@January2454 I think most people have heard Darin's version of "Mack The Knife" and certainly he "owns" the song, but many people have recorded it including Sinatra who purposely didn't record it while Darin was still alive because the song was so closely associated with him. However, recording artists like Patti Page and Ella Fitzgerald recorded some very interesting versions of i,t and in Ella's case a very famous live cover of it.
Nocaro 3 months ago 3
@January2454 BTW, Sinatra was a very elderly gentleman when this was recorded and had Darin lived this long and tried to sing it, his recording might have sounded comparatively anemic to a young Darin singing it.
Nocaro 3 months ago