atmosphere new order joy division wembley aren

new order play cover of joy division song atmosphere live at wembley arena 27th october 2006

Category:

Music

Tags:

• atmosphere
• new
• order

[bfd414]

Just to let all u people out there this is not a cover new order is joy divison without Ian Curtis

[cs009d4735]

is it really.... wow ur a fountain of knowledge

its a cover.. its someone singing someone elses song.... end of discussion

craigx

[hannahmwalsh]

Bernard, Peter and Stephen wrote the music, hence it is not a cover. If Ian wrote the words, and they all wrote the music, surely it can't be a cover?

[cs009d4735]

ok ok... if a band sing another bands song its a cover.... regardless of members

and who cares.... go get a life...

if u cant enjoy one of the greatest songs ever without being so fu*kin pernickety then do me a favour.... pop down to tesco and buy yourself a f*ckin life

love craigx

aka cs009d4735

[hannahmwalsh]

A bit pot calling the kettle black?

I was just pointing out something, and expressing an opinion.

Why does it matter so much to you that you get agro, is the question.

[cs009d4735]

yawn....

i dont consider new order to be the same band as joy division.... coz new order are pretty shit in comparison

so to me its two different bands... so its a cover

does anyone know how to stop youtube emailing me everytime one of you morons comments on this video?

craigx

cs009d4735

[ed1ss]

Who cares who wrote or sang it first. Its Ian's former band anyway, the only reason they changed the name was a mark of respect. Phenominal tune though, something really magical about it.

[MrMawsy]

new order shit? yeah whatever pal love vigilantes perfect kiss regret they r shit songs r they? glad i like shit then new order r wat joy division would of become it was ian who introduced kraftwerk into rehersals

[dirtydoris1983]

At this point I was slowly being crushed against the front bar by about 800 beer fuelled grown men - most of them looking like bouncers.... Fantastic gig though.

[ztoigo]

well i believe curtis wrote the lyrics

other than that, you could actually say new order wrote it, so its their song

maybe kinda like elton john bernie taupin. just cause elton john is singing it, doesnt mean its not his song, he wrote the music.

so is it a cover?

meh, kinda, not really.

[foxfac007]

Never knew that this existed. Speechless.

[thekillervinny]

If Peter, Bernard, and Stephen wrote the music, how is this a cover?

I didnt know you could cover your own music?