Uploader Comments (VinylToVideo)
Top Comments
-
Gigli had a very good high C, even if he never built his career on the top notes, as Lauri-Volpi did. If you want to hear some of his high Cs on record you can go to the "Salve, dimora, casta e pura" from FAUST (1931), "Che gelida manina" from LA BOHÈME (1931 & 1938), "O soave fanciulla" id. opera (1937 & 1938), and the finale of the love duets from MADAMA BUTTERFLY (1939) and UN BALLO IN MASCHERA (1943).
-
This chap was my dear old dads faverite.Thanks for putting this up.
All Comments (49)
-
man i want to be able to sing like that. F***what the popular music scene thinks. they don't know anything about anything before their time. My cohorts are a bunch of ignorant twats. It's so frustrating !
-
This recording gives us an idea of how good Gigli was and why he was and still is so highly regarded.
-
An inspiration for all later tenors. Great singing.
-
@dekercarol The chorus heard at the end of this clip was taken from the end of the opera. Quite a presumptuous move to cut and paste it there...



One of the best versions of this aria I've heard. It's in my top 5. No, Potts isn't even in my top ten.
I also like the chorus ending.
wiseroldfart 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@wiseroldfart Pol Pot shouldn't be in anyone's top 100 list.
VinylToVideo 1 year ago
@VinylToVideo: I hear you! I just got blasted by a Potts fan for saying he's decent for an amateur, but not in the same league as the great tenors. The truth hurts. Not everyone has a great ear for music. I like the guy and wish him well, but he'll never achieve greatness. I'd never pay to see him or buy a Potts recording - not in a world in which so many great tenors have been recorded.
wiseroldfart 1 year ago
@wiseroldfart I don't even bother commenting on the awful singers' videos anymore; their ignorant fans are always bound to make a reply and it's just a back and forth comment war that never ends.
VinylToVideo 1 year ago
The last minute of the recording is the chorus finishing the aria. We do not here this in the other recordings and I do not remember hearing the chorus in the 2009 HD performance. Is this change in the treatment of this aria?
dekercarol 1 year ago
@dekercarol It might just be another thing to boost modern tenors' ego, even if the tenors years ago were better equipped.
VinylToVideo 1 year ago