@foxy81516 On the one hand it is not possible that the MIB always was Christian, because Christian was sometimes very helpful and not evil. But on the other hand there are no evidences that the island impersonated christian.
@STUNTS1516 You can believe what you want to believe. But I 100% know that I am right. Watch the scene where Locke (MIB) tells Jack it was him. He's clearly lying. Think about it. Why would there be two versions of Christian? They are clearly different people. One is the MIB, one is the island. Period done, not talking about this anymore. There is not a doubt in my mind that I am right. And you are wrong about the writers. They never said that...
@STUNTS1516 No it wasn't MIB, it was the island impersonating Christian. The only time MIB impersonated Christian was when he was dressed all homeless like. i.e the "Christian" Claire, Lapidus?, Locke, and Sun saw was MIB. The "Christian" Jack saw, the clean cut version, was the island impersonating Christian. The Christian in this video is the island manifesting itself in Christian's body so to help guide the island's savior Jack figure out his destiny ... MIB was lying to Jack...
The reasons he's wearing both shoes there is because its just mib impersonating him, mib doesnt take peoples clothes he just looks like them hence why the real locke is still wearing his funeral suit when they find his body.
@pinkfloydrule27 it wasn't Christians shoe if you watch the first season over again you can see him wearing both of this shoes when jack is trying to catch him in the jungle
@CosmicUndeadElf Remember that Jack told Kate in episode 1 he doesn't remember being on the plane when it crashed, maybe he and others like Vincent and perhaps Locke were teleported from the plane.
@wjcrouse913 Yeah I know but back when I wrote that it hadn't been confirmed yet that Smoke man was Christian. One thing I don't get though, how can he be inside the cabin when it is surrounded by a circle of ash? I know the ring was broken but its never explained exactly when that happened.
Vincent is awesome.
zionravescene 2 months ago
@foxy81516 On the one hand it is not possible that the MIB always was Christian, because Christian was sometimes very helpful and not evil. But on the other hand there are no evidences that the island impersonated christian.
Chable5 11 months ago
@STUNTS1516 You can believe what you want to believe. But I 100% know that I am right. Watch the scene where Locke (MIB) tells Jack it was him. He's clearly lying. Think about it. Why would there be two versions of Christian? They are clearly different people. One is the MIB, one is the island. Period done, not talking about this anymore. There is not a doubt in my mind that I am right. And you are wrong about the writers. They never said that...
foxy81516 1 year ago
@foxy81516
No.
The mib said VERY clearly it was him, its confirmed by the writers on lostpedia.
The island cannot and has never immitated somebody.
The MIB impersonated chritian since the beginning.
STUNTS1516 1 year ago
@STUNTS1516 No it wasn't MIB, it was the island impersonating Christian. The only time MIB impersonated Christian was when he was dressed all homeless like. i.e the "Christian" Claire, Lapidus?, Locke, and Sun saw was MIB. The "Christian" Jack saw, the clean cut version, was the island impersonating Christian. The Christian in this video is the island manifesting itself in Christian's body so to help guide the island's savior Jack figure out his destiny ... MIB was lying to Jack...
foxy81516 1 year ago 2
@TheSkurryer
*Spoiler*
It was christians shoe.
The reasons he's wearing both shoes there is because its just mib impersonating him, mib doesnt take peoples clothes he just looks like them hence why the real locke is still wearing his funeral suit when they find his body.
STUNTS1516 1 year ago
@pinkfloydrule27 it wasn't Christians shoe if you watch the first season over again you can see him wearing both of this shoes when jack is trying to catch him in the jungle
TheSkurryer 1 year ago
OMG MOBISODES ARE AWESOME
catherine1495 1 year ago
@CosmicUndeadElf Remember that Jack told Kate in episode 1 he doesn't remember being on the plane when it crashed, maybe he and others like Vincent and perhaps Locke were teleported from the plane.
CosmicUndeadElf 1 year ago
@wjcrouse913 Yeah I know but back when I wrote that it hadn't been confirmed yet that Smoke man was Christian. One thing I don't get though, how can he be inside the cabin when it is surrounded by a circle of ash? I know the ring was broken but its never explained exactly when that happened.
CosmicUndeadElf 1 year ago