Uploader Comments (gianninak)
All Comments (14)
-
@uplifter1000 Dear shirtlifter: you highlight the problem with this kind of singer. You (as someone who sings) would liked to be judged HONESTLY. You would know (as do I) whether it be pop or opera. Different is OK. But bad is something different. Giordano was a construct of the music industry, a confection created and pushed by record companies. She simply cannot sing by any objective standard (pop or opera) - that's not a personal opinion but just simple plain fact. I love all kinds of music
-
Exactly - you either like it or you do not. But really, who are we to say if it is rubbish or not? That is judgement - we all appreciate different things in life. That does not make something good or bad. That is all I was trying to convey. The judging part - I can sing, too - but you may not like it - that does not make it bad. And - if I heard you sing, I might like it. I might like it better than this song - but it still does not make this one here bad. xx love
-
@uplifter1000 So nobody can appreciate anything (art or sport) without being able to do it themselves? Artists singers perform for us. We either like it or do not. BUT, when people are saying Giordano has a marvellous voice/style that will provoke comment. As it happens I can sing it "better" although I suspect that I am not regarded as attractive to look at as Miss Giordano.
-
I think folks who are quick to criticize should be required to post a link to their version singing same song and let us decide after listening....
so, you have a recording of your magnificent voice singing any better?
-
What a load of rubbish - she just can't sing.
Estasiante l'ascolto di questo brano classico di Verdi interpretata dalla bravissima Filippa Giordano
Davvero un incantevole ascolto
Grazie amica Gianna
******
Il tuo amico Lillo
amarcordeon 1 year ago
@amarcordeon
Grazie,Lillo!
Ti auguro una serena nuova settimana!
Un abbraccio
gianninak 1 year ago
Meravigliosamente dolce e trasportante la canzone, un bellissimo montaggio video, i mei più sinceri complimenti cara amica Giannina....un bacione grande!!!! Vola nei miei prefs!!!!!!
Angelo58GH1 1 year ago
@Angelo58GH1
Grazie,Angelo!
Buon inizio della nuova settimana!
Un abbraccio
gianninak 1 year ago
bel video :)
piccinasis 1 year ago
@piccinasis
Grazie,un abbraccio
gianninak 1 year ago