LESS THAN 1 MINUTE LONG Falsetto @ the end . I tried to do a little bit of what i coined ' vocal acrobatics 'or what i have subsequently heard others call vocal gymnastics ......... BUT -without trying to overdo it (as so many do ) . oh and a little falsetto too for those who are easily impressed by these overemphasized singing Characteristics .
YOU HEARD IT HERE FIRST !
THERE IS A HUGE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN BEING " A GOOD SINGER " AND "HAVING A GOOD VOICE " ! ! !
I have never heard of anyone who promotes this idea but i hope that one day it will be universally understood and accepted .
I WILL USE ALL CAPS BECAUSE IT IS EASIER TO READ - ESPECIALLY FOR THOSE WITH WEAKER EYES .
VERY FEW WOULD DISAGREE THAT MARIAH CAREY AND WHITNEY HOUSTON ARE INCREDIBLY TALENTED , TECHNICAL SINGERS . BUT DOES THAT MEAN THAT THEY HAVE GREAT VOICES ?
MY ANSWER IS " NOT NECESSARILY " .
POWER AND CONTROL DOES NOT AUTOMATICALLY EQUAL BEAUTY .
LET'S IMAGINE THAT THERE WAS A WEIGHTLIFTING SEGMENT FOR " MISS AMERICA " HOPEFULS . WILL THE STRONGEST WOMAN AUTOMATICALLY WIN AS BEING THE MOST BEAUTIFUL ? ?? OF COURSE NOT . THE BEST DANCER IS NOT ALWAYS THE ONE WITH THE FASTEST FEET . IT'S AN ART WHERE SPEED HAS A TIME AND PLACE WHY IS IT THEN THAT PEOPLE ARE AUTOMATICALLY DESCRIBED AS HAVING GREAT VOICES BECAUSE THEY HAVE INCREDIBLE TECHNICAL SKILL OR POWER WHILE SINGING ?
THE ANSWER IS THAT NO ONE HAS COME UP WITH THIS IDEA YET .
RULE # 1. JUST BECAUSE YOU ARE A GREAT SINGER DOESN'T MEAN THAT YOU HAVE A GREAT VOICE .
RULE #2. VICE VERSA
THESE TWO EXPRESSIONS ARE SO MIXED UP AND INTERTWINED THAT IT'S ALMOST RIDICULOUS .
ROBERTA FLACK , MY FAVORITE FEMALE VOCALIST , WAS A GREAT BLACK FEMALE SINGER WITH A SUCCESSFUL CAREER IN THE LATE 70'S AND 80'S . SHE NEVER DID ANY " VOCAL ACROBATICS " THAT I KNOW OF , BUT WAS ABLE TO HAVE HIT AFTER HIT . SHE WAS NOT A TECHNICAL SINGER OR A " BELTER " OF SONGS - BUT I DON'T CARE . SHE HAS A TRULY BEAUTIFUL VOICE - ALTHOUGH SHE MAY NOT BE THE BEST "SINGER" IN THE WORLD COMPARED TO WHITNEY , MARIAH OR CELINE . I COULD LIVE A HUNDRED MORE YEARS AND NEVER HEAR THOSE THREE AGAIN AND STILL DIE HAPPY . I PREFER TO HEAR SOMEONE THAT SOUNDS GREAT WHILE SIMPLY SINGING - NOT SHOUTING OR MOVING ALL UP AND DOWN THE MUSICAL SCALE WITH LIGHTNING SPEED AND THE PRECISION OF A RICHTER SCALE . THAT JUST DOES NOT IMPRESS ME VERY MUCH AT ALL .
JUST THINK HOW SUCCESSFUL THOSE THREE WOULD BE WITH ALL OF THE "BELL'S AND WHISTLES GONE " .
THERE ARE THOSE FEW SINGERS WHO HAVE THE BEST OF BOTH WORLDS . THE BEST EXAMPLE THAT I CAN THINK OF NOW IS CHRISTINA AGUILERA . VERY FEW WOULD ARGUE WITH THE FACT THAT SHE HAS INCREDIBLE VOCAL CONTROL BUT ALSO A NICE VOCAL TONE THAT SO MANY OTHERS ARE LACKING .
YOU MIGHT NOT AGREE WITH MY EXAMPLES HERE BUT IT'S ALMOST IMPOSSIBLE TO DENY THAT MY BASIC POINT IS PRETTY TRUE . I HATE TO EVEN USE EXAMPLES BECAUSE MUSICAL TASTES ARE SO DIVERSE - BUT I HAVE TO , IN ORDER TO PROMOTE MY IDEA .
I SEEK TO ACHIEVE MY GREATEST ABILITY IN BOTH SEPERATE CATEGORIES BECAUSE I BELIEVE IT TO BE VERY IMPORTANT - WHETHER OTHERS REALISE IT OR NOT .
IN SPITE OF ALL OF THIS , THE BEST SINGER WITH THE BEST VOICE CANNOT SOUND GOOD WITH THE WORST SONG IN THE WORLD .
and so many people will hate me now, Britney, for example, actually does have a pretty voice but is a horrible singer.
I am with you all the way on the misunderstanding thing, and I've thought about it too for a long time, however you must remember that "simply singing" for some people is avutally belting. A friend of mine with a beautiful voice has never had any vocal training, but is able to nail songs by MC, WH, and CD easily. She can sing everything naturally. It's second nature to her.
roojooroojoo 3 years ago
A great example of a beautiful "voice" would be Norah Jones. A voice that I would not call beautiful would be Shakira . James Taylor did lots of "vocal acrobatics" in "How Sweet it is" but his voice is kind of wierd to me - twangy or nasal - something wierd, but a good technical singer. I hope this adds clarification to my essay on the big difference between being a good singer and having a good voice .
rolenvi 3 years ago