Ehud Olmert Speech in University of Chicago 1 of 4
Top Comments
All Comments (151)
-
Palestine has its right to have defense ,but not on the cost of Israelis security.
Since until now every weapon given to the PA was used against Israelis (mostly civilians) ,you have to agree that giving more weapons will not end the war...
-
Yasser Arafat was held in Ramallah ,only after the 2nd Intifada began. On his orders. Until then he was able to move freely in Gaza and Judea and Samaria's Palestinian territories.
Speaking of Arafat ,did Suha eventually return all the money he stole from the Palestinians for his own good?
And what about Gazan graffiti on the wall ,that mock Gilad Shalit?
Not to mention a bunch of Palestinians that were documented inside an Israeli prison running a play ,that mock Gilad Shalit.
-
You missed my point.
Palestinians had their Palestinian Police ,until their guns were pointed at Israelis.
Not as a defensive act.... but purely offensive ,on a joint patrol!
-
So, regulating daily life activity and security even in buses in Israel is 100% okay, but for Palestinians having a defense mechanism and having a typical police patrol unit to maintain population security is not okay? This does not make sense at all!
-
Lets not forget the total deaths by Israeli army killing Palestinians listed before as well as the following: Yaser Arafat, the Palestinian president could not get out his own territory in Ramallah becuase of Israeli army. Israeli army jeep kills Palestinian student in West Bank in 2009. Israeli Army T-Shirts Mock Gaza Killings. I can go on and on. Palestine has its right to have defense and if Israel does not give the Palestinian groups a peace treaty, Israel would be threatening its own self.
-
I am very sorry to hear about your incident ,assuming you really meant no harm to anyone.
But do you know since the terror attacks that begun around Oslo agreements ,every Israeli mall ,restaurant ,public place ,has a security person that checks in everybody's bags?
Do you know that Israeli train stations have x-ray machines for thepassangers' baggage?
Yes ,just like in airports!
Yet ,no one complains about the inconvenience because they all know ,it's for their own security.
-
These joint patrols ,they were the point of Israeli-Palestinian co-operation. Until this murder.
So ,unless Israel can trust PA that its army will be defensive ,and not not offensive ,the PA will have no way to defend itself.
Would you give a gun to someone ,knowing he will point it at you?
And you still have to answer my questions about who is a Palestinian?
-
Do you remember the Palestinian Police?
Taken from Wikipedia about the 2nd Intifada:
"In the West Bank city of Qalqilyah, a Palestinian police officer working with Israeli police on a joint patrol opened fire and killed his Israeli counterpart Supt. Yosef Tabeja, an Israel Border Police officer."
The Palestinian Police was established as part of the Oslo agreements.
Israel had the same thought in mind ,but eventually this force was used to murder on a joint patrol!
-
So, you did not answer my question, how can a country be established without a defense mechanism. You know our human body has a strong cellular and humoral immune body triggeting Tcells and B cells to protect us from infections. You can see how AIDS progresses when the immune system is destroyed. Thats how a country would be with no defense mechanism. I can not imagine Israel without defense. It simply will not last. My question to you my friend is how can Palestine "a country last without it?"
-
We all know Israel has the upper hand in any borders involving the Palestinian. Please stop making it as if Egypt is the problem. We all know anything that goes in Israel and out of Israel is controlled by Israel, You know last year, when I went onto a visit to Palestine, I had alot of Andies, Receies Pecies, Skittles, Hot cheetoes, cloth, pants, laptop and I had to stay in the security point for hours and hours!!
wow we have hear a man who has no basic knowledge in history, filled with logic fallasies, trying to teach other people history... man, you have no idea what you are talking about... i looked in your antisimetic website and its filled with nonesense and fallasies like all holocause deniars "claims"... get realistic... get a therapist... many people have discussed the holocause and no "claim" ever stood up because you are using false propagnda and thats not the way sciense works.. 2 bad 4 u.
delirious2k3 2 years ago 3
it s true that the arabs and the persians are semites, however today the word semite is mainly used to deifne jews.
ashkenazi jews started looking like europeans after they left israel 2000 years ago. hence i guess the ashkenazi jews might not be genetically semite but they remain labeled as semite.
mrheryou 2 years ago 3