Maria Joao Pires gives piano masterclass (1)
Top Comments
Video Responses
All Comments (278)
-
Totalmente de acuerdo con Des Abends
-
First of all the student plays well!
It's for this reason that she tries to say something and the result is so..silly!!
I am sorry to write this,I like Maria Pires as performer!
-
it sounds stupid to me when he playsmusic and then he says probably its wrong... how can you play if you dont even know what you are playing...
-
@rodrigobrizuela few people know that
-
great teacher !bracvo leave me a comment in u tube theagui100 thanks
-
@bemaniac2 do you know what is wrong what you do nor love anymore to somebody? Well, music is the same my friend :)
-
@DesAbends As other, you have no idea what you are talking about. Learning piano is not about learning style or ideas, is about feeling. And all she does is helping him to feel and discover the music as she understands it. Later on, he will develop his own ideas. Your statement is pure hate speech.
She keeps telling the student that she doesn't get any "feeling". Where have I heard that...? Everywhere, all the time. One single common place (the most common of all) constitutes her master class. But not a word (one single word) about music.
arturonoyolarobles 1 year ago 6
It's above all ridiculous that he must almost apologize to her for his musical choice. There is not only a single way to understand, represent and feel the music (and the Art in general). She is trying to make him a miserable copy of her, Maria Pires number 2. I would never go to a masterclass when the professor has not respect for my ideas. I think the masterclass is useful only to improve the pure technical skills. Once you are technically ready, play the way you feel better.
DesAbends 7 months ago 4