Tarja Turunen Hamburg 2008 Wishmaster

Compare this version of Wishmaster by Tarja Turunen and her new band to Nightwish with Anette.

Category:

Music

Tags:

• Tarja
• Turunen
• Wishmaster
• 2008

[petsitterlinda]

This is not one of Tarja's best. She's a bit out of tune and sings ahead of the band.

[justanamehere]

"She's a bit out of tune and sings ahead of the band. "

I don't find it out of tune anywhere, nor do I find her singing ahead of the band. Could you point out an example in terms of a time frame in the song where you find her singing ahead of the band or out of tune?

[koas145]

"if anything,without Tarja,Nightwish is nothing"

This is your opinion,right?

Nightwish´s new album is selling more than any NW album EVER before,it has awarded many multi platinum and gold awards and have been top 1 on the charts on many countries,and their concerts are selling more than ever too.

Tarja sold platinum in Finland,wich is good,but she hasnt sold any serious numbers in other countries

So,It seems Nightwish is going on well without her

[koas145]

this quitarist ruins Emppu´s awesome solo....

I dont like Tarja´s solo,sorry =(

She was good in NW,but with her solo career she is nothing

LONG LIVE NIGHTWISH!!!

[soundslikeblue]

The sound quality doesn't help ... but we all know that Wishmaster is one of those signature songs from nightwish that Tarja always made perfect live!

And I think that it is good to see her perform this song, in fact the song would never be same if she hadn't sung it ... probably it would not have been even written the same way...

Anyways I wish the best to both nightwish and Tarja!

[Titti0913]

Well, I think in this situation all of the members were guilty, not just Tarja or Tuomas. I believe in you, when you said they didn't call Tarja about a concert, but i think there was a reason. I dunno what, but 4 men didn't do these things because they just want it. I think most of the band disliked Marcelo, and not Taraja, cause he wanted to do everything, and bother with not just Tarja's stuff, but put his foot in the band's.

[Titti0913]

I think it isn't out of tune. Maybe you hear that, because of the quality, it's not the best, but I think Tarja is good here. :)

[Titti0913]

No. I like Nightwish with Tarja, or with Anette, for me it's doesn't matter. I just said that, Tarja's band is half as good as Nightwish. And of course, i know it isn't the best video. It's close to the original, you are right, closer than Anette's version (I hate that king of wishmaster). And don't misunderstand me, i do not hate or dislike Tarja. I don't like her band... and her accent, but it's another thing...

[justanamehere]

Remember, this is a shitty 3rd generation recording originally captured on a cell phone. In other words, it was downloaded from YT and uploaded to YT again.

Sure, it might not sound as crisp as Wishmaster on the End of an Era DVD, but it's VERY close to how NW used to sound like. For you to say Tarja's band sucks while performing it must mean you thought NW sucked when they used to perform it with Tarja.

[Titti0913]

Actually Tarja did write beautiful songs, but i have to say, that with the other part of your comment I totally Agree. Tarja is better in singing. Her own songs are a bit boring, but IMO beautiful, too. :)

[Titti0913]

Yes, Anette sucks with Wishjmaster, but Tarja's band sucks with it, too.

[Nightowljrm]

"Compare this version of Wishmaster by Tarja Turunen and her new band to Nightwish with Anette"

I personally like both versions. On this song, yes, Tarja outdoes Anette. (But I like Anette's version of "The Siren")

Also... Jukka probably never sees his kids either. =o