Did Lady Gaga rip off Natasha Bedingfield?

Comparing their songs.

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• lady gaga
• natasha bedingfield
• so happy i could die
• pocketful of sunshine

[fahd08]

my god!!! who hasn't she ripped off!

[Biene1989Bo]

Of cause Lady Gaga is copying most of her songs. Because she's smart. She knows that the people will talk about all this Copied stuff and because of that her Songs climb higher and higher in the charts.

[msfunnybunny101]

@Yukihiro21 Thank you. You're the only one who's being mature here :)

[willKCFAN]

i preferrrrrrrrrrr a million times natasha than gaga, what a shame gaga, is clearly similar.

[Yukihiro21]

@xPowderBluLolipopzx I'm not sure when you got the idea where she act's like she's " original" but you're dead wrong. It's her FANS putting her on a pedestal. She;s done nothing but make music. Calm down. and this is coming from someone who doesn't even like her all that well.

[Yukihiro21]

@BigRedEO and it only proves the quote" The more success someone has, the more shade you'll get." and this is someone who's studied music theory for years and has play an instrument for years as well. If you're a music major then you SHOULD know that somthing like this is not NEW cause even in in the classical music genre songs sound similar right down to a friggn syncopated rhythm. I wonder why people don't put vids up for them calling the directors " unoriginal" ? hmm...

[Yukihiro21]

@BigRedEO only the staccato eighth notes and the chords are similar. It's not the same style of music at ALL! The fact of the matter is, WHO CARES? Natasha Bedingfield Isn't original either. No one is Original ! cause it's all been done before. I'm not a big fan of Gaga but these Vids are absolutely stupid.

[BigRedEO]

@Yukihiro21 - As a music major, I can tell you that is MORE than the chord progression - it's almost the exact same melody, down to the staccato eighth notes!

[Yukihiro21]

Why do you people waste time with vids like these. Yes, the song has the same chord progression. So does another million songs do. Hell if that's the case then Natasha Bedingfield ripped off a song someone else cause I'm sure someone has made the song in that EXACT same cord before. ON ONE OWNS CHORD PROGRESSION!

[PungiFungi]

I always thought the Express Yourself/Born This Way comparison was a bit out there. But in THIS case, when the song's melody is so similar, I can't help but wonder.

[anoziraflaminghot]

@Biene1989Bo actually she's not climbing higher and higher on the charts. all her latest singles flopped except "born this way". and her album sales dropped by 85% once her album was no longer available for $0.99. i think her star is fading. and fast.