Sugar Mice Somewhere Else Tour

Marillion Playing (without rehearsal) Sugar Mice at Aula Magna 17th April

Category:

Music

Tags:

• Sugar
• Mice
• Straws
• Marillion
• Hogarth
• Somewhere
• else
• Aula
• Magna

[batebatev]

fish cannot sing anymore, at all and the voice of steve is unique and powerful

[antigoon78]

I'm sorry too, but I think you're wrong. I think H manages to leave the songs feel completely intact, and still make it his own. I also think this is a great comlpliment for Fish since H rarely agrees on playing Fish-era songs. The fact he starts it on his own means he wants to sing it.

Futhermore, Fish nowadays can only sing this song when it's transposed 3 halves down. And, for me Fish has lost all his magic years ago, where Marillion still make great music, and continue to grow...

[alexandergenov1984]

@batebatev  това последното можеш да го отнесеш към себе си!

[batebatev]

@alexandergenov1984

vsichko e vapros na vkus, priatelu

(i na predrazsadaci razbira se)

[alexandergenov1984]

@batebatev I disagree! It's true that Fish can't sing anymore, but there is nothing unique and powerful in the Steve's voice. There is only one Marillion - Marillion from the Fish era. Anything unique and powerful in this group belongs to that time.

[TheEspadrille]

It's Fish's song, but on balance, its not half bad -still a great song to lift the crowd

[victorvei]

marillion no es fish

[fdvirtudes]

I thik they shoud have had a new start after Fish left them, building a new band with Hogarth or whoever, with a new name. I find it repulsive to read people writing about "Fish era", for there is no other era for Marillion. After Fish there is something else. Not Marillion.

[fdvirtudes]

@mojos2006 I totally agree with you, the song is destroyed. I respect people who like Hogarth (I don't), but he should sing only his own material. It's not like if he had arrived yesterday, he's got a large reportoire and he must stick to it.

[kenuzy1]

A great beautiful version of a superb song.

[Jacoisms]

Nothing here is bad... This tune was recorded in 86 by a young group of artists not yet beaten by time, age, and the abuse of a now dieing recording industry. Acually to my sober ear this sounds awesome... Its the crowd in the background that is obviously intoxicated by the elements - and are likely clutching at straws like those of you who insult without gratitude for the person who posted this.. I saw this tour in 87 and then in 1990.. Fish was not with them in 90 - but in rehab..