SWING WITH The Marx Brothers
Uploader Comments (luizoak)
Top Comments
-
Are you kidding me--racist and denigrating? I challenge you to find a mainstream white film from 1935 that has such a prominent role for African Americans. The Marx Brothers had well known sympathetic leanings toward minority groups. Not to mention that, as Jews, the Marx brothers probably felt the sting of discrimination themselves. Other than African Americans, Jews experienced more discrimination in this country than any other group.
-
Well spotted - and featured several other members of Duke Ellington's Orchestra. I think the boys were brilliant comediams. Their routines were pure Vaudeville and they were around long enough to know what was good and what worked. Kept in the context and spirit of the movie, it shouldnt offend anyone. (No more than James Brown offended people as the preacher in The Blues Brothers). It's comedy - relax!
All Comments (29)
-
les ha jodido el polvo a la pareja de blanquitos que estaba en el granero
-
I'm pretty sure it was Harpo that brought on the Duke Ellington Band and thank goodness Ivie Anderson. It's so hard to find any of her music.
-
@hovanti - to quote Fats Waller "This Joint is Jumpin!"
-
Only an ignorant and innately racist person would find this scene to be denigrating. It is your belief in your role as the benevolent protector that is racist and demeaning. This is a national treasure that should be held up as one of the crowning achievements for Marx Bros movies. It is also a proud moment when some of the most amazing music & dance ever performed by EXTREMELY talented people was available for all of America to see (whether the performers were Black, Jewish, or ?) .
-
Perhaps the last great Marx Brothers movie; probably because Thalberg had hand in it before his untimely death. My favorite film of theirs and this is one of the highlights. Thanks for posting it! (PS: The movie came out in 1937).
-
One of my fav sequences in all of the Marx brothers films. So beautiful, they're so talented! I want to swing dance!
-
I like how the house is shaking at 1:50; now THAT'S swinging!
-
@ThwartedVillainy yeah i know. its sad though...people considered this racist that i know
-
@CharlieChaplinsAngel He'd get arrested if he tried that these days.



We can make an anology with the sotry fo the Hamelin falutist maybe, thou he didnt lure rats, only the chilrdren an the rest of the ppl, also not to lock them in a cave but to release their souls and bodies with the sound fo the swing music. :)
luizoak 2 years ago
Vídeo errado. Sorry ^^ Estou upando o Tutsi com LEgenda.
luizoak 3 years ago