"The PLO was on record..." -Norman Finkelstein
Uploader Comments (mbrown0315)
All Comments (226)
-
It's hilarious how you equate the actual genocide being perpetrated on the Palestinians by the jews with the empty statements of those being exterminated. You place no stock in actual events, death tolls or any kind of sanity. You're a laugh.
-
@kokogro please do your own research to confirm the following: 13/09/93 yassir arafat on jordanian TV - "since we cannot defeat israel in war, we do this in stages. we take any & every territory that we can for palestine, and establish sovereignty there. and we use it as a springboard to take more. when the time comes, we can get the arab nations to join us for the final blow against israel." said on the very same day he signed the olso peace accords!
that's just 1 example of the complications
-
I hope there is never a 58th Muslim terrorist state. The Arabs do not need yet another state, pushing Israel into Abba Ibin's "Auschwitz lines."
-
Your argument is riddled with holes. The record clearly shows the Arabs have been voting for a 2 state solution honoring the 67 borders. Debunked.
-
HAHA-finklestein ur a fuckwit.My family fought that war in Lebanon.the PLO was ethnically cleansing Lebanon of Christians.They were firing into Israel & running into Lebanon.Israelis were attempting to stop the external attacks.The Christians who werent involved in the jihad were armed to defend themselves & rid the country of the armed plo.It was mutually beneficial.Murders,rapes,kids being shot.Someone had to stop it.No one did.Lebanese Christians thank the israeli boys for their sacrifice.
-
My agenda is hate? My agenda is justice, equality, freedom and self-determination for all. Your agenda is apartheid, chosen people / master race, just like Germans thought they were the superior people you believe that Russian Jews have the right to go to another country and demolish the natives' home and kick the residents out. Based on your logic there never was such a nation called "Jews" who had a country called Jewland so that means Jews don't have the right to have a country.
-
yonatan shapira is same as the other thing and they do it out of need of attention and of course autoantisemitism these things are no different than the nazzis. Such things are not new for the jewish people and we understand they exist. Good for them
-
@optimistsRUS this is my argument.i dont just discredit it. this thing shouts at jews not to "abuse" the holocaust while it doest it itself. Where he is wrong? 1st there was never such a nation called "palestinians" that is why they cant claim for anything especially no land and no rights.
u and such are far from the truth since u have no idea about history and politology. your agenda is HATE. holocaust survivor who support flotilla sold his number as if it was a taxi.
-
"Israel is a country of Jewish immigrants"
So? Is it bad?
"it was founded by Jewish terrorists"
That's lie. It was not factor. Brits were going to leave anyway. There was nothing for them to hold for
Your numbers are bullshit. Absolute majority of land in this area was gov. land and private property confiscated by arabs from jews is 5x of entire Israel.
-
Yawn... calling someone a "Self-hating" Jew is not an argument, it means that you have no argument against him and his facts are true and the only thing you can do to discredit him is throw dirt at his motives. Care to highlight where exactly Finkelstein is wrong? Anyone who stands up for truth and doesn't play the bitch of Israeli terrorists is a self-hating Jew? Yonatan Sharpira and 82 year old Holocaust survivor who went on Jewish flotilla to break Gaza siege are also self-hating?
Even Barghouti is too intransigent for you? Of course he desires the dissolution of Israel as we know it. What self-respecting Palestinian wouldn't? Obviously, the two state solution is a ploy for both sides of the conflict -- it is an offer the Israelis cannot accept, and the Palestinians do not desire.
ListenLiberal 2 years ago
No, there are people on both sides who are serious about the two-state setup. As far as I can tell, Salam Fayyad and other Palestinians with a less revolutionary history are more interested in international investment and other aspects of serious state-building than in carrying on a war of liberation. There's just not enough of them.
mbrown0315 2 years ago
Also, I couldn't help but notice that you said "the dissolution of Israel as we know it," as if these people really just want a Middle Eastern Switzerland...just a peaceful bi-national abode where two linguistic communities can live peacefully side by side. This is funny to me, and it gets funnier when people make the claim that this is actually what the Arabs wanted all along. Even if they did want to maintain a Jewish national presence, peaceful bi-nationalism simply won't work at this point.
mbrown0315 2 years ago
The peace is there now? What is "working" now? The peace you envision is a pernicious peace in which the Palestinians essentially give up. That is no peace at all. That is a victory for the bad guys. And it assumes, incorrectly, that the Palestinian bargaining position weakens over time. Our Little Serbia ain't so tough.
ListenLiberal 2 years ago
The peace I envision is a partition setting the framework for both sides to gradually outgrow their respective nationalisms and irredentism while collaborating in various realms of commercial enterprise, culture, and security. Where does that lead? Probably Belgium, maybe even Switzerland if we're lucky. As I've said before, partition needs to precede real bi-nationalism. That you just write off one side as "the bad guys" makes it nice and clear that this conversation is pointless anyway.
mbrown0315 2 years ago