dude i have absolutely no a clue what a scale is apart from ot is somethin my sister plays on her saxamophone apparently :D but i can still tell you that this cover is posibly the worst peice of shit i have ever heard of ever !! haha it is shocking :D xx
Lol this version sucks. Replace Marr's complex chiming appeggios with genric power chords = shit. The guitarist cannot even bother to do the complete intro or replace it with his own interpretation (which I would have prefered to see).
Fan's of this version probably do not know what a scale is, and thus cannot appreciate the ornate sonic interplay of the orginal Smiths version. Also the singer sucks, theres no feeeling there apart from a depressed emo-like tinge.
Maybe it's because I heard this version first, I'm not British, I'm not from the 80's, and I'm a Death Cab fan, not a Smiths fan. But I think they really took a good song and added a twist to modernize it and make it better.
dude i have absolutely no a clue what a scale is apart from ot is somethin my sister plays on her saxamophone apparently :D but i can still tell you that this cover is posibly the worst peice of shit i have ever heard of ever !! haha it is shocking :D xx
thefunkychief 2 years ago
i like both songs
xsystemofadown23x 3 years ago
great video. but i hate covers
suchafoot 3 years ago
lmao the music and vocals don't match the lyrics at all ... They sound anything but "charming" lol
cryspatus 3 years ago
fantastic.
i dunno what the guys below are on about, great music video, great song
i loved the animations
well done
jacklemons 3 years ago
the words are wrong
baloobas1 3 years ago
They should turn down the volume of the guitars a bit.
I think they did the song justice, but you can't beat The Smiths' rendition... its a classic.
dannehFREAK 3 years ago
Lol this version sucks. Replace Marr's complex chiming appeggios with genric power chords = shit. The guitarist cannot even bother to do the complete intro or replace it with his own interpretation (which I would have prefered to see).
Fan's of this version probably do not know what a scale is, and thus cannot appreciate the ornate sonic interplay of the orginal Smiths version. Also the singer sucks, theres no feeeling there apart from a depressed emo-like tinge.
Chandicuts 3 years ago
I agree with you too.
Maybe it's because I heard this version first, I'm not British, I'm not from the 80's, and I'm a Death Cab fan, not a Smiths fan. But I think they really took a good song and added a twist to modernize it and make it better.
Great video by the way.
comeonnowsugar 4 years ago
they butchered a great song but good vid
Superdeluxe94 4 years ago