The World Turned Upside Down

Jack Brindelli's idea on a world with no state. Your responses please.
Honours:
#29 - Most Discussed (Today) - News & Politics
#26 - Top Favourited (Today) - News & Politics
#28 - Top Rated (Today) - News & Politics

Category:

News & Politics

Tags:

• Talks
• Turkey
• Politics
• Government
• State
• Anarchy
• Chaos
• World
• Turned
• Upside
• Down
• Jack
• Brindelli

[truthadvocate]

Your critique of the state is great, but your socialist beliefs are deeply flawed.

Everyone gets an equal share? Will a 7 foot 250 pound man get the same portion of food as a 3 foot 60 pound dwarf? Equality is a bad idea, because no two human beings are created equal. We all have unique needs, desires, values & preferences. Your worldwide socialist society cannot work because it ignores the unique nature of individuals.

Free market anarchy is far more practical.

[JackBrindelli]

@truthadvocate Wait, you're an 'anarchist' and you're lecturing me on what's practical?If you're looking for practicality why not just conform to the syst- wait a second,market anarchy?Yeah, you already have. As for your totally unflawed critique *sargasms* of equality, from each according to his ability to each according to his need is the kind of equality im driving at, people get their fair share for a change.

[Killarat5]

I'm an anarchist I have been for a long time, u seem 2 be describing anarch-communism, I am simply an anarchist becuz I find authoratarionism ethically immoral. I find ur portrail and interperatation very good, and correct thanks for putting this video up anarchists don't get heard well enough(if at all) and we certainly ain't understood

[JackBrindelli]

lol cheers, glad you liked it

[overmind25]

and the nature of such invasion is not changed, whether it is made by one man upon another man, after the manner of the ordinary criminal, or by one man upon all other men, after the manner of an absolute monarch, or by all other men upon one man, after the manner of a modern democracy."-

Benjamin R. Tucker

[bobomber]

On the government as a scapegoat: I find Noam Chomsky's explanation makes a lot of sense, that government gives people the potential for real democracy and so it is logical that ruling elites try and instill a fear and hatred of government in the public.

[truthadvocate]

@JackBrindelli,

I've conformed to the system? The current system is statism, a democratic republic, crony corporate capitalism. That bears no resemblance to free market capitalism nor to market anarchy.

In free market capitalism, what people produce is determined according to the needs of consumers. Prices fluctuate daily reflecting the purchasing decisions of consumers and thus serve as a vital indicator as to what is needed & desired. How will your system determine what people need?

[JackBrindelli]

lol coming from you, logical is interesting, considering you entire argument about the troops is based on emotion rather than rational thought. and people banding together is the point! they will help each other in order to survive. selfishness gets you no where in a world where the selfish are no longer protected by states.

[MC2minshall]

yes but poeple will band together... like they did in the past to create groups etc etc, the fact is your little plan is stupid.. it wont work, be logical

[JackBrindelli]

lol good idea all the same

[JackBrindelli]

i dont know if you noticed, but personal greed ruined this one already. personal greed wont really stand up without a state or police force to protect it either. if it ever rears its ugly head, it will not be able to exploit the workers a second time. unless you want to try of course. if you want to face a revolution, be my guest.