609 Would Anarchy Create Governments?

Private contract agencies - will they ride the black helicopters into the hearts of the masses?

• Category

  Entertainment

[simplethunder]

Oh shut up you pompous bigot.

[DabbledInBlood]

Yes, there is something wrong with that.

Reason and logic are more important than emotion.

It doesn't matter how you feel, but what benefits everyone else.

And if you can't understand "big words" then you probably shouldn't be debating over the internet in the first place.

[simplethunder]

My argument is emotional, is there something wrong with that? It's about -my- beliefs, after all. And what part of my reasoning is illogical? I can give you a reasoning behind why I think government is the embodiement of evil in mankind.

And stop it with the fancy wording. If anything you're making it harder for people to understand what you're saying.

[DabbledInBlood]

straw man

- a logical fallacy in which the arguer creates a distorted representation of the opposing argument and argues against that representation rather than the actual argument.

Your entire argument of why you are an anarchist is based around an illogical, emotional argument of arguing against your subjective connotation of government rather than the actual objective dictation of government.

[simplethunder]

Do you even know what 'straw man' means?

I'm not assuming anything. I'm giving you the reason why I am an anarchist. Anarchy doesn't create governments because when it does, it stops being anarchy and it starts turning back into modern society.

[DabbledInBlood]

More straw man arguments.

And you assume that everyone would "rebel against human evil".

You forget that some people are the essence of human evil.

Voluntarism creates a society where everything is aloud to be done voluntarily, including murder, thievery, rape, fraud, and breech of contract.

Minarchism creates a society where everything is aloud to be done voluntarily EXCEPT for murder, thievery, rape, fraud, and breech of contract.

[DabbledInBlood]

I can't get through 5 minutes of this.

At 5:20 you go directly into the straw man of comparing THIS government with the government I envision.

Nothing you have stated would be possible, AT ALL, in a minarchist government.

[DabbledInBlood]

"Reputation is the most important thing in the world for a person."

False. Many people care nothing about their reputation, and plenty of them _want_ a bad reputaion.

Adam Lanza did not care if people thought bad of them when shooting those children.