Nightmare Revisited Poor Jack

and marilyn manson's version of this is halloween was awesome, they totaly grasped the 'halloween' aspect of it ^.^

ur so right, plain white t's could have done the cheery what's this, and flyleaf could have done the depresssing poor jack. but its not that bad

hmmmm... well, it's not COMPLETELY awlful.... it's just... not up to expectations. I like the original better. They definately could have gotton someone better to cover this song.

I actually really like this version.

Bass is great in this song!

But you guys are right, Flyleaf and Plain White T's should have switched, although I think this way we can get a whole new look on "What's This?" along with "Poor Jack."

All I have to say is wow. Not wow as in a good thing, or a bad thing. But I did notice that he was trying to act through his singing. Which he sucked at. I do agree that these guys and Flyleaf should've switched, but no use griping about it. This is what we got.

i dont like this one either....its a shame all american rejects and plain white t's ruined the album....

i think flyleaf should of did this song and plain white ts should of did flyleaf's

plain white t's are really upbeat and would have done what's this so well! and flyleaf would have totally captured the sadness of jack :(

so.....i totally agree with you!

i really dont like the way flyleaf did that song... I mean its supposed to be really up beat and full of bliss and joy... but they totally made it depressing... which isnt what its supposed to be... unlike what KORN did when they totally owned and brough out the dark and synysterness in that song haha