Honestly, both amazing, i would say evenly amazing. Brodeur has better record than roi but he also had a better defensive team to back him up. I'd say that makes it even.
They're both great goalies, but Brodeur was on a team with amazing defence (Niedermayer, Stevens, Rafakski, & Daneyko holy crap!) that trapped the crap out of every game.
Not that the Avs or Habs had bad D (Blake, Foote, Bourque on the Avs; Robinson & Chelios on the Habs) but they weren't on the same page.
No coincidence that after Niedermayer & Stevens left after '04 the Devils never got out of the 2nd round.
Plus, in their head-to-head match-up, Roy won. Gotta give it to Patrick Roy.
i think the sad part is that brodeur is gonna retire either this year or next year, and hockey will lose both the greatest goalies, I would pick Brodeur because of all the accolades he has, he holds more records than Roy, but Roy is still the 2nd best, and extremely close behind Brodeur, and to everyone saying Roy revolutionized the butterfly stance, just so you all know Brodeur revolutionized the HYBRID stance, its a very close call, but devils fans say it the best, MARTY'S BETTER! MB30 FTW
Brodeur easy! Patrick always had a beast of a team to play in front of him. Brodeur did not always have one. New Jersey has only been dominant for the last 15 years ish. Although Roy would still have the wins record if his career didn't get cut short, Marty has done a lot more
Honestly, both amazing, i would say evenly amazing. Brodeur has better record than roi but he also had a better defensive team to back him up. I'd say that makes it even.
jebaman42 1 month ago
i'm not anti roy but i feel that the amount of time given to brodeur is much less and thats y i disagree with you mr turnupthevolume.
skinnyboyjerk97 3 months ago
They're both great goalies, but Brodeur was on a team with amazing defence (Niedermayer, Stevens, Rafakski, & Daneyko holy crap!) that trapped the crap out of every game.
Not that the Avs or Habs had bad D (Blake, Foote, Bourque on the Avs; Robinson & Chelios on the Habs) but they weren't on the same page.
No coincidence that after Niedermayer & Stevens left after '04 the Devils never got out of the 2nd round.
Plus, in their head-to-head match-up, Roy won. Gotta give it to Patrick Roy.
TheSkookumchuk 4 months ago
martin brodeur
ripjoebg1 4 months ago 2
i think the sad part is that brodeur is gonna retire either this year or next year, and hockey will lose both the greatest goalies, I would pick Brodeur because of all the accolades he has, he holds more records than Roy, but Roy is still the 2nd best, and extremely close behind Brodeur, and to everyone saying Roy revolutionized the butterfly stance, just so you all know Brodeur revolutionized the HYBRID stance, its a very close call, but devils fans say it the best, MARTY'S BETTER! MB30 FTW
G0r3gasm 4 months ago
@caca98019 Haha 2 years later and I still laugh at that comment.
sammydems 5 months ago
Man Roi was the best in Montreal...what a dumpass compilation!
pokeysaurus1 6 months ago
Brodeur easy! Patrick always had a beast of a team to play in front of him. Brodeur did not always have one. New Jersey has only been dominant for the last 15 years ish. Although Roy would still have the wins record if his career didn't get cut short, Marty has done a lot more
xXxRawkFistxXx 6 months ago
@MrFlyersFreak no broduer is 2nd best .... no doubt roy is best though
TheEmergencyJamUnit 6 months ago
Roy= Best of all time and will always be! martin broduer=Pussy
MrFlyersFreak 6 months ago