Emmy Destinn -Suicidio - La Gioconda by Ponchielli
Uploader Comments (MrCafiero)
All Comments (13)
-
I actually like her voice. I like how she approaches that high note at 1:38.
-
beautiful - thanks!
R.
-
Awesome! TY.
-
Superbe voix ! Mais je n'adhère pas au maniérisme de la plupart de ses fins de phrases. Les notes tombent souvent. Mais bon... c'est toute une époque !
-
1914.
M.
-
MrCafiero, thank you so very much for sharing your wonderful collection of singers from the golden age. In that period there were basically 2 types of singers: parlor singers, and opera singers. The great singers had not only beauty and balanced registers, but tremendous power capable of filling an opera house over a huge orchestra. Singers today are spoiled by microphones that allow them to get by with poor vocal technique. These recordings are critical to understanding great singing.
This is an exciting performance but the voice itself IMO is not partifulary beautiful pr round. There is a bit of a braying sound which I find unpleasant and in this aria, I prefer Ponselle and Milanov.
65attila 1 year ago
@65attila Did you hear her live? Of course not and it is very difficult to judge a voice like this based on such limited recording equipment.
MrCafiero 1 year ago
what a horrible accent she has , makes me roar
papoocanada 2 years ago
@papoocanada That isn't an accent as much as it is a language called Italian.
Also, she was fluent in 5 languages and was a great translator. Admired by Caruso, Toscanini etc.
MrCafiero 2 years ago 3