Harry Potter and the half blood prince : In Noctem (Deleted Scene 1)

its not what any die-hard potter fan hoped...its sad to see a great book destroyed with a horrible movie! i wish the movie stayed true to the book...

It is very great deleted scene, especially with Snape. But I think it had to be deleted because of the very impressive facial expression. Could anyone of us say whether Snape was evil then? Of course I read the last book but the audience had to think Snape still to be evil or ambivalent during this movie. And this absolutely great acting of AR would destroy the supposed effect.
Sorry for my english for it is not my native language.

I agree completly! :) It is my favorite deleted scene!

Why the oppugno scene and NOT THIS? There isn't justice.

yup. the choir is so good.. really touching. i wish it was on the film :(

anyone know what actual choir this is?

This makes me angry because everyones been saying, "oh, they didn't leave this scene in cause it gives away too much." Like come on! Its just a couple of seconds on Alan's face. I think the expression he makes right after he kills Dumbledor gives away more than what he does in this scene, but oh well.

Essa cena é perfeita, não deveriam tirá-la!!

I agree.. should have been left in the film.
Yet another thing they've done wrong.

i wish they left this im the movie made it so much better