JS Bach: Himmelfahrts-Oratorium
Loading...
Link to this comment:
Top Comments
All Comments (43)
-
Madeuf et al with their natural trumpets are incredibly bold and it's admirable. But I can't help thinking I'm willing to sacrifice a bit of historical authenticity for the sake of intonation. There's an especially sour chord in 0:18 and it's just unpleasant to hear. Maybe when they've truly mastered herunterreiben they should use them, but for now, I think I'm in favour of vent holes.
-
Lovely cantata but i prefer bigger choir in this opening chorus.
-
the instruments, when they are confonted with a regular choir, they switch back a bit. but with the soloists they feel on equal footing.
-
Wunderbar!
-
@PeriodinstrumentfaN Hi! I don't know exactly what instrument was used by Thibaud Robinne (1st trumpet) but Jean-Francois Madeuf used in the first part of the concert (Ch.P.E.Bach) his copy of an english natural trumpet by Graham Nicholson (the one in this extract is one of his many trumpets, but he also plays sometimes an original instrument from 1st half of 18th century) Nicholson himself as 3rd trumpeter in this recording plays one of his own copies.
1 year ago 2
-
@GBADCD well I would not dare to say, that he is an Iditot or ridiculous!!!! There's evidence, for both positions! So maybe Bach used just 4 singers in the "normal" sunday cantatas and more on festive days? How about that? And so far a choir with 30 people are also not what Bach had in his mind. He had also not more than 3 singers per voice! And also Bach didn't use 12 violins! So concerts by Herreweghe or Koopman sound nice but really historical I wouldn't call them too!
-
@richie132 And if you want to hear excellente performance of the "Himmlfahrts Oratorium" buy a CD of Herreweghe and Gustav Leonhardt. Now that's BACH.
- 7:51
Bach, J S , Cantata 11, BWV 11, "Lobet Gott In Seinen Reichen" 4 Ach, Bleibe Doch, Mein Liebstes Lebenby tobe72,174 views
- 4:43
Bach BWV 11 Choral (Coro) Wann soll es doch geschehenby aefive8,657 views
- 4:36
Johann Sebastian Bach, cantata BWV 11, choral finale "Wenn soll es doch geschehen"by Mozartharmony36,319 views
- 6:11
J. S. Bach - 'Pastorale' from the "Christmas Oratorium," BWV 248by Op13937,534 views
- 4:44
Bach Lobet Gott in Seinen Reichen BWV 11 Part 4 Harnoncourtby TheGravicembalo3,589 views
- 2:37
Sigiswald Kuijken - Suite nr 1 BWV 1007 couranteby ChallengeRecords45,995 views
- 8:37
Christmas Oratorium J.S Bachby Zerlina1227,915 views
- 2:11
La Petit Band / Sigiswald Kuijkenby Jezraelmtz13,041 views
- 3:25
Sigiswald Kuijken - Suite nr 1 BWV 1007 preludeby ChallengeRecords28,331 views
- 1:02
Tintin themeby theunderminor9584,781 views
- 3:54
Wenn soll es doch geschehenby arklas2,957 views
- 2:19
J.S. Bach: Preis und Dank (Osteroratorium BWV 249)by ssiroe12,481 views
- 5:33
BACH - Oratorio de l'Ascension BWV 11 - Thomanerchor - dir. Kurt Thomas ( 1960 )by RIRRATTO2,547 views
- 10:13
Joseph Haydn - Die Jahreszeiten (1801)by Edreno53,834 views
- 8:17
Weihnachtsoratoriumby 1Johnny111114,375 views
- 4:36
J.S. Bach- Johannes-Passion - Von den Stricken meiner Sündenby bran4805154,120 views
- 4:06
CPE Bach: Die Auferstehung und Himmelfahrt Jesuby Edreno10,641 views
- 14:38
Bach Himmelfahrtsoratorium, Ascension Oratorio BWV 11 Kuijken Part1by ArioniaTellus1,395 views
- 1:28
Welkomstconcert Sigiswald Kuijken Kortrijkby stadkortrijk2,378 views
- 8:10
Bach Lobet Gott in Seinen Reichen BWV 11 Part 3 Harnoncourtby TheGravicembalo3,187 views
Logisch es gibt kein Worter für dieses himlisch schöne Musik.
ritamaria55 2 years ago 5
Awesome. I really enjoyed the period instruments. Trumpets were the best. Great job!
cdctrumpet1 2 years ago 3