Much Ado About Nothing (1984 TV) - Act I, scene 1
Uploader Comments (ShakespeareAndMore)
Top Comments
-
Not completely true. Cherie Lunghi is working her ass off, as are Robert Lindsay and Lee Montague. They're let down by many of the others , who seem disinterested at best. The messenger seems to be suffering from sleep deprivation, or brain damage. My recollection of this version's Don John (Jon?), is that he was actually worse than Keanu Reeves, by some margain.
In summary, less fun than Branagh's version, with some redeeeming features.
-
Cherie Lunghi is superb..... Wow.
All Comments (92)
-
Wich I could speak English like them
-
hark at all these televisual experts rant their opinions. I'm sure Shakespeare would be thrilled to see such in depth analysis of his wonderful comedy.
But it is wonderful :D
-
so after watching this version a couple times... I'm pretty in love with this benedick, haha! anyone else? he's just so sincere. ther's so much going on in his eyes
-
@ishtarg8 Though our perception of smiles, gestures, and nods may be ultimately incommensurable, I would like to think that our assessment of the acting situation could be reasoned out. I would proffer that nearly everyone in the cast is under a light sedative (Leonato, Claudio, etc.) and that this is not only a valid acting choice but more profitable than the Branagh direction (really quite giddy). Would REAL people laugh out loud at EVERYTHING that Beatrice says?
-
@ishtarg8 Yah, that to me is more than a fair assessment of the character. And I think your characterization of his manner as ophidian more than hints at your complete acceptance of this interpretation. Ophidian is most certainly what he is.
-
@MrMucas I have to disagree here. The messenger is terrible. I think the confusion you're seeing is just the poor guy's default setting. He's clearly under the influence of some powerful sedative, or severe head trauma.
Ultimately, I just prefer the energy and joie de vivre of Branagh's, over the rather more sober presentation here.
Of course, "Taste is a matter of taste," as Tad Allagash tells us, and is ultimately inarguable.
-
Keanu nails this line as well. And Richard Briers' reaction is wonderful. Mr. Broodingly Handsome isn't going to spoil the fun! Phew! I just think Keanus' dynamism is a better reading than this guy's rather ophidian immobility (not to say torpor) though I do admit, now, that it... may, possibly, be a valid choice.
I have a friend who thinks the whole John/Conrade exchange is charged with sexual tension, at least in the Keanu version, which may also add interest, if you agree.
-
@MrMucas For such an essential character (he's the plot's catalyst; without him we have a bunch of rich folks partying at a villa) Don J. is rather underwritten. My own assuption about him is that he's a sort of proto Edmund, from Lear. He's a guy who, because of an accident of birth will never have the position he feels he deserves. This is the " limitless occasion" that breeds "sadness without limit ". It also makes him the least hypocritical character in the play.
does someone has the version with Derek Jacobi??? PLEASE!!!
dorica91 2 years ago
Derek Jacobi played Don Pedro in a television adaptation of "Much Ado about Nothing" for the BBC in 1967. The BBC archives would probably be the only source for a copy of this production.
Derek Jacobi alternated Benedick onstage with Cyrano de Bergerac with the RSC (and Sinead Cusack as Beatrice/Roxane) in the early 80s. The "Cyrano" was filmed for TV, but the "Much Ado" wasn't. I'll upload the "Cyrano" to YouTube in a few weeks.
ShakespeareAndMore 2 years ago