Toccata & Fugue in D minor (BACH, J.S.)
Uploader Comments (latribe)
Top Comments
-
Quite honestly, I think this is one of those pieces that's almost impossible to criticize unless the organist blatantly sucks. Let's face it, this is very unusual for Bach (and indeed may not be Bach at all), and it's one of those few pieces attributed to him that actually allows expression and variance-and in this case, a LOT of it. I rather like some of the things he's done with it, truth be told. As far as I'm concerned, with TFDmoll, the organist can go anywhere he damn well pleases.
-
For sure, it deserves 5, exactly what I gave it.
Some people just don't seem to understand the word "interpretation".
"it's too fast, it's too slow, the registration is wrong..." just a couple of the favorite comments by organists here, all related to PERSONAL taste.
All Comments (24)
-
At 1:19 the sequence that begins there is used as music in the computer game called "Rick Dangerous", it is an old game on the commodore 64 and commodore Amiga
-
I've seen that video! I tool the liberty of converting it to an MP3 and put it on my iPod. It's an excellent rendition (and that organ is a monster).
-
@willowthebored It's worth searching St Maximin Bach for another interpretation of this piece on an amazing instrument.
-
@willowthebored Hi! It's worth searching St Maximin Bach for another interpretation of this piece on an amazing instrument.
-
@willowthebored Hi! It's worth searching "St Maximin Bach" for another interpretation of this piece on an amazing instrument.
-
it's a toccata. its meant to show off the organist's technical skills according to his own interpretation.
-
Five stars, for it is not an easy piece, and someone worked a lot to get here. Bravo! and keep it going! I agree with the interpretation comments. I also have the same problem sometimes, only on classical guitar. But the organ is my favorite instrument of-all! I don't think I'm ever going to have the chance to study this instrument, but still... Music is Music, and J. S. Bach is GREAT! :D All the best regards! :) Interesting organ tho'... (Electronics everywhere :)), but I like it! )
-
so faril
-
Toccata & Fugue in D-minor... NOT Bach? What heresy...what drivel! Perish the very idea! I think I'm going to faint.
-
Great sounding organ - and a VERY talented doctor - Medicine AND Music??
Wow.



:-) So what areas in this piece are not as intended and should other performers performers avoid?
latribe 2 years ago
Hello!
I think the organ sounds incredibly good! You can see that David is a very talented organist but it seems like he has not practiced very much. He still reads from the sheet and misses a little bit sometimes. It is also a pity that he did not use the 64ft and 128ft stop.
It would be interesting to hear what eg Ton Koopman thinks about this organ. :)
Again latribe, I am very impressed with the organ!
patrikjonsen81 3 years ago
Thanks for your compliments about the organ. It's really intended to be inspirational as a concert instrument for the repertoire as well as an experimental breadboard for organists to try different styles and combinations of stops . . . to inspire real pipe organ building, and for practice for major concerts.
David - WOW he really IS AMAZING. He works as a doctor in the Congo for 11 months of the year and can practice in Kampala once every three months. He really wants a pedalboard in Congo.
latribe 3 years ago