Francis Poulenc - O Magnum Mysterium
Top Comments
All Comments (55)
-
never met you but I love you already
-
WONDERFUL!!!
-
I'm not discounting Robert Shaw's decision to put the low Bb in. (and I'm referring to the one two leger lines under the bass stave; which is heard here and which is absolutely NOT in the printed score) Poulenc may well have approved his decision to put this note in. But it's gilding the lily, surely.
-
@pawdaw The low B flat is there because it's in the score. My guess is that Poulenc put it there. My choir is singing it this year from the 1952 Editions Salabert, which, I would guess also, was set while the manuscript was still wet from his hand. And, for closure, the first note the bass sings is also that same B flat.
-
@ pawdaw: Speaking as a bass -- because we can.
-
all the people arguing on here....wow... i had hoped that educated people would be more mature than the people that argue on every pop/rock singers' videos. but alas even here people have to prove that they are right.
-
@mightyafrowhitey I completely agree with you! I have nothing to be added to your statement
-
Omg people who cares about that last note? Its freaking BEAUTIFUL! that's all that matters:) I still wish my choir was doin this piece:/
I can understand why you might think the low Bb is just wrong for the chord. It's not traditional. But it's something I would want to include in that chord as well, if I were composing this. There's something large, open, and icy about that last chord. Like you're in a bright castle made of ice, but you're completely warm and at home in it. Or, you're standing on a mesa, staring out over a wide landscape as a slight breeze blows around you.
That Bb belongs.
MrPoog 1 year ago 23
Sweet memories...learned this 40 years ago.
hairstonnyc 2 years ago 7