DOCTOR WHO: The Companions
Uploader Comments (lesather)
All Comments (60)
-
There's five characters that have been missed from this sequence Michelle Ryan (Lady Christina de Souza), Lyndsey Duncan (Adelaid), Bernad Cribbens (Wilfred), Karen Gillan (Amy Pond) and Arthur Darvill (Rory).
-
PLUS, I know this came after this video was made, but she got quite an adventure in The Stolen Earth/Journey's End.
-
Except for the Mel scream, I liked the video.
I don't know if Liz got to travel in the TARDIS. If she didn't, then therefore, by extension, she isn't classified as a companion using your logic. And if memory serves me, the Brig did travel in the TARDIS during a Fifth Doctor episode. Yates and Benton, yeah, that's debatable. Also, Jackie Tyler did have a flight in the TARDIS ("My mum's on board.") Granted, that was a hop from the Powell Estate to Canary Wharf, but still a ride nonetheless.
-
Pff - If ADAM gets to be in it, The Brig AT LEAST should. Just because he wasn't a regular TARDIS traveller that's no excuse to be excluded. He was one of the Doctor's closest friends and they knew eachother for half their respective lives.
Even so - I do love this video.
-
If Liz gets included (Who I may add, was the Doctor's ASSISTANT, and never actually travelled in the TARDIS), then the Brig, Benton and Yates should be too. They were all primarily members of UNIT, and the Brigadier in particular had far more effect on the Doctor's life than Sara Kingdom who only appeared in ONE story, or Katarina who was in two.
-
That was so fun to watch that Mel's scream took me by utter surprise.
-
Awesome!
-
@20meerkat Romana!
-
Who was the one that was dressed like the fourth doctor? Weird
-
i dont think jack harkness was really a companion
Cool vid - I think it's good that there's some differences in opinion. Chang Lee counts for me because he was hypnotised, lied to, threatened and killed by the Master before the Tardis brought him back to life and the 8th Doctor's acceptance of him just shows what an extraordinary Doctor he was.
We all could probably argue forever whether Adam was the first "usuitable companion" too.
flashrobbie 2 years ago
I had a conversation with Yee Jee Tso about this at the recent Chicago TARDIS convention and he pretty much said the same thing. He saw himself being considered a companion to the Doctor because he helped get the 7th Doctor to the hospital, then he gets dupped by the Master into helping him and finally ends up helping the 8th Doctor.
lesather 2 years ago
Really good but where's the Brig?,also Captain Yates and Sgt.Benton are classed as companions too.
dramaticguy 2 years ago 2
I felt he Brig., Yates & Benton were recurring characters and not companions, since the Doctor's "companions" during that time were actually Liz Shaw, Jo Grant & Sarah Jane Smith. In the new series you wouldn't consider Jackie Tyler a "companion" would you? I also wouldn't have included Mickey Smith if it were based on anything prior to the ending of "School Reunion".
lesather 2 years ago