Sergei Rachmaninoff plays Schumann "Carnaval" Op. 9
Uploader Comments (truecrypt)
Top Comments
-
If pianists played like this today, they would be immediately kicked off the stage or booted from a competition. Total originality, like two gods battling, Schumann's split personalities and Rach's brooding humor and sadness. Listening to this reminds me of why i play.
-
Two masters! Schumann and Rach
All Comments (60)
-
@QueenofMalinlorien, ermm...was the man, i.e. he was awesome!
-
3 people are idiots, Rachmaninoff is the man
-
@New4785689 Is it just mee or the sphinxes are kinde of freaky and scary they hunt me all night
-
This piece is very sweet, is very clear and very soft... is so beautifull... without words.
-
It is said that if Rachmaninoff was to play "Carnavale" in New York NO other pianist would bother to perfrom it that season !! I think that this performance displays why !
-
@truecrypt thanks!
is he playing sphinxes with a tremolo? why? 8:50
New4785689 1 year ago
@New4785689
"Sphinxes" is more an *idea* than actual piece and was not intended for performing by Schumann.
Rachmaninoff-composer couldn't miss an opportunity to re-create Schumann's abstract "mind game" into real character - grandiose and mysterious.
truecrypt 1 year ago
@truecrypt I wonder whether it reflects a historical performance practice for this piece---ie. it was customary for an improvisation to be inserted.
wrdna58 1 year ago
@wrdna58
I hear more improvisational spirit than improvisation here... Rachmaninoff's performance is very individual(istic?), but everything is played "as written". His implementation of "Sphinxes" is not an improvisation either - rather an attempt to voice and revive "mute" images.
Back to your question about "improvisational inserts" - I think it was pretty typical!
One can only guess how Liszt himself would play it!!! ;)
One caveat though... “Quod licet Jovi non licet bovi"!
truecrypt 1 year ago
Хотелось бы узнать: какого года эта уникальная запись? Спасибо!!!
Vikrussia 2 years ago
1929
truecrypt 2 years ago