Near Death Experiences & Atheism part 5 of 5 A.J. Ayer - apologetics
NOTICE
This video contains an audio track that has not been authorized by WMG. The audio has been disabled. More about copyright
Uploader Comments (grandconjunct)
Top Comments
-
emmit says that "similar" experience have been performed and shows Howards experience is imaginary..lol that's like saying if I print monopoly money "real" money doesn't exist..lol wacko-athiest..and OBE's are not NDE's I've had OBE's and they are nothing like what Howard is talking about..
-
Part 3> Environment does not make blind people see for the first time during their NDEs or Deaf people hear for first time during NDEs or Jesus to be seen in foreign NDEs guess again mrPoor54.
where you are born is irrelevant though it may explain your irrational rejection of this video and NDEs out of hand without first studying the subject.
Environment explains nothing about NDEs
other than their reality, Atheism offers no explanation of NDE, in fact atheism explains precisely nothing
All Comments (39)
-
got to get some sound!
-
why did they remove the audio???
-
Ann Rice wrote the forward to Storms book "my descent into death" (see link in sidebar) and she is the one who supported him to get it republished!
see Wikipedia article on Howard Storm.
-
ann rice.. the author of Interview with a Vampire? That is very cool. Can you please give me a ref on that? thanks
-
You were kinda tuff on him but your points were very valid!
-
Part 2> Howard was only in Kentucky to be a materialistic missionary to unenlightened religious folk at the secular University he taught at.
Your ability to Listen is worse than your faulty reasoning abilities.
Actually it is very common for people in other cultures and countries who have never even heard of Jesus to say they saw a being of Light who told them his name was Jesus, even Naturalistic NDE researchers admit this so your "guarantee" needs a Refund.
-
Part 1> From the bible belt? Gassp! I forgot to check his genetic Origin before taking him seriously! by the way you forgot to mention where you are from, so we can figure out if you said anything true ? Blue Neck reasoning anyone ?
by the way you are wrong Howard was born in Blue State New York which explains his blunder of being an atheist, by your standard Eh dude ?
So if Mr Poor54 is from New york Or San Fransisco then I can dismiss your comments as a product of environment not reason right?
-
For "Christ" sake, this guy is from the bible belt, what did you expect him to say? If he grew up in Japan without knowledge of christianity I Guarantee you he would not be talking about Jesus. If christianity was true, people from non christian countries (Japan, Saudi Arabia etc...) would be saying the same thing after their NDE's but they don't. I'm sure Storm had this experience, but when giving details it all boils down to him being a product of the environment.
All I saw when leaving my body was an exact but odd replica of this world. Nothing like that religion nonsense angels, hell, heaven etc..
Lacktardo 3 years ago
Lacktardo>> "EXACT but ODD replica of this World" ??
grand >> Is reality Odd to You ??? if it was EXACT How do you know it was not really this world you were observing ?? Are You aware that NDEs start with STAGE 1 "THIS WORLD " Real world events like Hospitals floating above your body or ambulance (that can be tested for accuracy after returning) then proceed to STAGE 2, "OTHER WORLDLY" events , Heaven, Hell, God etc?? Yes religious folk are well aware that some people revive before stage 2, So?
grandconjunct 3 years ago
very interesting. gives me hope and scares the crap out of me at the same time. so many questions. im even more confused now. but in a good way. i think.
HLecterPHD 3 years ago
This is a good place to ask questions, plus it allows myself and others to learn.
grandconjunct 3 years ago