Heinrich Schütz - Musikalische Exequien - Herr, wenn ich nur dich habe

Howard Arman, Schütz Akademie

Category:

Music

Tags:

• herrwennich
• 0001

[bigmandrel]

I hear a great deal of this on posted commentary; that is, a preference for this recording or that recording. Who cares about such absolute statements of taste? My favorite "recording" of this work, or any work, is the one I last attended in concert, or the version that I "played" in my head an hour ago. If you care about the music, care about the music, lest you degrade it to some cheap, collectible commodity, like trading cards. Music lives inside you; the specific performance matters little.

[togga84]

wonderful, this perfekt voices, excact and straight

[chimoio100]

just enjoy the tune pretentious tithead!

[Nachtmarchen]

@todwfish Gardiner is too aggressive and clipped for my tastes, the German diction is lacking as well - his recording does not convey the distance of the choir representing the departed either (Arman's is about the only one that gets it right).

[carlosvg1986]

@bigmandrel stop hating haters! oops i'm just as guilty now :D

[todwfish]

@bigmandrel Spare me the pretentious rhetoric, please.

[franciscokch]

I knew the music of schutz years ago, very good , fascinating and beautiful

[elufologo]

Thanks for your kind reply. I do have Gardiner's performance as well. But, honestly I prefer the older approach, I mean the 50's, 60's and some 70's. Thanks.

[todwfish]

I prefer the Gardiner interpretation.

[elufologo]

Sublime! Second only to Mauersberger and the Dresdner Kreutzchor performance.

[wasummenouebbe]

Heavenly!