Two Sisters - Jim Moray
Uploader Comments (DangerYourselfCopies)
Top Comments
-
Thumbs up if Kate Rusby and Jim Moray should do a duet.
All Comments (15)
-
WOW! He does a haunting version of that song..
-
@gaspode18 I'm all for preservation of English tradition ~ I'm just in the middle of baking my first Lammas bread!
-
@SilverWolfMoon You're probably right, actually. This probably IS a Scottish song (borders, anyway). I was just making a point - English tradition DOES exist and is worth preserving, despite what certain ex-Ministers of Culture (yes, Kim Howells, I'm pointing at you!) might think.
Take a trip down to Kent next May Day weekend. The Rochester Sweeps Festival is one of the biggest Morris dance festivals in England. Well worth a look.
-
@gaspode18 As it happens, I'm English!
As a fan of Folk music, I know that a majority of traditional songs are English with the occasional 'Celtic' varioation. But songs like this, with many known variations in the Celtic parts of the Isles {and abroad} are more likely to have originated in Scotland or Ireland - for example, Julie Fowlis performs two Scottish interpretations of it, 'Wind and Rain' and 'Thig am Bàta'.
Maybe we should just call it traditional 'British'...?! :)
-
@SilverWolfMoon Could just have easily gone the other way from England. I frankly get a bit fed up of ALL folk songs from the British Isles being claimed as 'Celtic' (mostly by Americans, it has to be said) - Even songs that are KNOWN to have been written by English songwriters within the last 100 years.
-
@gaspode18 Well... Scotland, Ireland and Wales are 'Celtic', and it was probably transposed to England from one of them since variations of the song are known in all 3, and apparently also in Brittany...
-
@SilverWolfMoon Not really Celtic, it is known all over the British Isles, including England.
-
Really good. Can't describe it in words.
-
It's a traditional Celtic song, known by several titles, most famously 'Two Sisters' {Clannad}, 'The Cruel Sister' {Pentangle, Old Blind Dogs} and 'Wind and Rain' {Julie Fowlis}.
The lyrics and plot vary slightly in each version, with the drowned sister either just dying {'Two Sisters'}, or having her body turned into a harp {'The Cruel Sister'} or fiddle {'Wind and Rain'}.
One of my favourite songs, and I especially recommend the Old Blind Dogs version :)
my gosh i'm sorry, i did it again. this is probably a song that has many versions
mahogonywhisper 2 years ago
Hehe not to worry.
Most of Jim Moray's songs have a traditional origin, this one is Scottish I think. Look up Twa Sisters on wikipedia, there is a list of versions by popular artists.
If you want to know more, you'd have to ask on the forums, youtube won't allow me to post the link here though.
DangerYourselfCopies 2 years ago 2