2009 09 13 亞洲星光大道
羅力威 - 說好的幸福呢
亞洲星光大道:
Contestants: unattractive, cannot sing (with 2-3 exceptions)
Hosts: professional
Judges: constructive opinions, emotionally attached to contestants
The band: zomg, REALLY bad
Competition system: a BIT boring but at least it's stable and you know what to expect every week.
Verdict:
羅力威 has potential. Super 'pop' and will def. sell loads. I think it's acceptable that he sings Jay Chou so much, but if he does, he shouldn't rearrange the melody too much. When you don't recognize the song at some points, that's when you know it's overdone. Improve on his music sense (piano playing is alright, ad-lib and harmonies are bad) and he's easily the winner.
亢帥克 - love his voice but he's gotta work on his breathing/use of mic.
李昊嘉 - her first performance ("Vincent") blew me away, but she might not be as good with pop.
超級巨聲:
Contestants: overall very good, with an exception to a few bitches
Hosts: rude and dim-witted (except gary, as least he can SING and is entertaining)
Judges: note to all - singers don't necessarily know how to judge/comment. shitty judges that either i) don't give any comments or ii) give UNconstructive criticism or iii) criticizes the wrong things
The band: good. sound system's good too, altho all the mics minimized reverb (it's a TVB thing)
Competition system: "WTF". there are like 100 episodes easily for this. the show eliminates 1 contestant every 5 episodes and they'll get re-picked again. Some bitches/shitty contestants are kept JUST because of dramatic/tv value. Too much political motivation..
Verdict:
Polar opposite of the other show. No clear favourites as of yet. Though I must mention 駱胤鳴 and 何雁詩 can't really sing (technique is SO bad) and whoever disagrees can come to me and i'll explain to you exactly why and smack some sense into you.
超級巨聲:
Contestants: overall very good
what have you been watching? 亞洲星光大道 miles better
feckmachine 1 year ago 4
@feckmachine
well you can see the time of my post
if you still think season 1 asia millionstar contestants were better than season 1 the voice contestant, then you let me know
KIT0426 1 year ago