JUSTIN BIEBER STEALS FROM LIZ PHAIR? MISTLETOE VS. WHY CAN'T I?

As you all may know, Justin Bieber has recently released his Christmas video for "Mistletoe". Since then, many have claimed that Bieber stole from Liz Phair's song "Why Can't I?". Did Justin Bieber steal from Liz Phair? You decide.

Category:

Music

Tags:

• liz
• phair
• why
• cant
• justin
• bieber
• mistletoe
• in
• my
• opinion
• think
• the
• two
• sound
• similar
• but
• dont
• that
• he
• intentionally
• stole
• it
• let
• record
• show
• rules
• and
• sucks
• its
• just
• opinions

[MazzieFace]

Just so you guys know, I don't even think he intentionally stole the song. They sound similar, yes, but I don't think that means that he stole it. I just wanted to upload this video so that you all could decide. I am not a hater of JB.

[maddymud]

T H E F T. Just the first stanza melody. Not the chorus ... He sing it lighter and breathy, and she pushes her's more, but it's the same stanza melody ...

[ItBrandonSilver]

He steals from aything because he is a DUMBASS American.

[buzzfugazi]

If he's stealing from Liz Phair, he's not stealing enough.

[FanofJordanTodosey]

no he didnt. lol sounds nothing alike.

[JulzofStudio08]

Theft?!?!!? I forget that Bieber fans are a little young, as am I. But I've listened to enough music to know that most pop songs consist of the same three or four chords. These two songs have the same melody, but they are completely different moods, intensity, and THEMES. I'm not a huge Bieber listener, but I do respect his musical talents; and to call his song theft, is pure idiocracy (<-- i think i made that word up),

[cutiepie123890]

In my opinion, it doesn't sound alike at all. But that's just me.

[abcdefckk]

OMG there r so many remixes, stolen songs, etc. why do you even care? how about you try to listen some tehno, HCT for eg. those guys remix everything and its not stealing, they just remix it and sometimes sounds better then original. MOH also take quotes from movies not just songs and i think its gr8.

[littlemissangel211]

omg its sounds exactly the same tune!! hes copied every song probably cos he obviously can't even sing and doesnt know how to do his own songs so copies other peoples! urghh he annoys me that boy.

[clarisabartol]

cualquiera

[TheBeautifulbrittany]

they d sound the same a little...

[solomon2093]

I thought Justin Bieber copied jason Maraz...Im yours. That sounds a bit similar.