Bid'ah - Hamza Yusuf

This is chapter 15. Watch the full lecture here: http://youtu.be/Seupm5QoZPo

Terms of Use: We are the original producer of this video. You have our permission to upload it to your YouTube channel as long as you do not edit the content or cover up the Islam On Demand on-screen graphic. You are NOT permitted to upload this video to any website other than YouTube.

Please subscribe to our YouTube channel at http://www.youtube.com/islamondemand where you can watch all of our FULL-LENGTH, original productions for free!

Islam On Demand
http://www.IslamOnDemand.com

Category:

Education

Tags:

• Hamza
• Yusuf
• Islam
• Muslim
• Islaam
• Bidah
• Bid'ah
• Bida
• Bidaa
• Bidaah
• Bid'aa
• Bida'ah
• Innovation
• Deviation
• Sunnah
• Sunna
• Salafi
• Da'wah
• Dawah
• Wahabi
• Sufi
• Shia
• Shiite
• Shite
• Shi'a
• Shi'ah
• Sect
• Sects

[umadkhan50]

I wouldn't listen to this guy. He was an advisor to Goerge Bush. The biggest mass murderer of our time.

[IslamOnDemand]

@umadkhan50 You're making it sound like he was part of Bush's administration! Subhan' Allah, he met with Bush in the days after September 11th and "advised" him that Islam had nothing to do with such an act of terrorism. He also gave him a copy of the Qur'an.

[IslamOnDemand]

@TheQuranAndSunnah And your proof is???

[haitham1984]

Salam Alaikom All,

Just wanted to say that I wished Hamza Yusuf would of made the distinction between the scholars of Saudi Arabia that are against celebrating the birth of the Prophet (pbuh) like Sheikh Bin Othaimeen and Sheikh Bin Baaz and the rulers of Saudi Arabia celebrating their 100 year independence. The two are not synonymous on many different issues and hence Hamza Yusuf's remarks, I believe, are unwarrented.

Jazak Allah Khair and May Allah Reward us all for all our Knowledge

[Madhofd]

@TheKap1an Thats where you are wrong brother. Your understanding of the term 'bidah' is incorrect. Bidáh means innovation in the dean. Technological innovations are not included in this. Innovation in ibadah (worship) is what bidah means.

[brain2770]

@TheKap1an

Yes let us stop here.

Please brother forget about me but for yourself , go study the fundamentals of Sunnah

study this hadeeth for instance

عن العرباض بن سارية قال وعظنا رسول الله موعظة وجلت منها القلوب وذرفت منها العيون فقلنا يارسول الله كأنها موعظة مودع فاوصنا قال اوصيكم بتقوى الله ... الى ان قال انه من يعش منكم فسيرى اختلافا كثيرا فعليكم بسنتي وسنة الخلفاء الراشدين المهديين من بعدي عضوا عليها بالنواجذ واياكم ومحدثات الامور فان كل محدثة بدعة وكل بدعة ضلالة وكل ضلالة في النار

[brain2770]

@TheKap1an

Dear brother Listen to your brother I sewer I understand you love the prophet. F U keep telling yr mother I love U but U do not buy her what she wants, y're helpless

The prophet gave instructions so that his deen would not be altered little by little along the time line. Strict adherence is the key. Just follow and he'll love u.

I fight bida so that everybody can see Islam as original as the prophet left it for us, untouched,complete, neat , and great.

Do u like it tampered with?

[brain2770]

@TheKap1an

If you do not know say so and stop suggesting things in the deen of Allah. It has been completed and save Muslims from your bid'az . Every one can be a philosopher and justify things . We have sahaba, Tabeen to follow not HAWA. Be ware you are playing with the most beloved person's Sunnah . He left us a huge heritage to adapt to and we leave the main solid road and choose the narrow zigzagged ones..

If you want to be honored at the Hawd stay clear and respect Sunnah. He taught it all

[brain2770]

@TheKap1an

You picked up one point that was obvious "No one said the Prophet forgot things" ok

Please answer my questions

1 what was the exact birth date?

2 Who did it in the first 300yrs the best three centuries How was it mukhtalaf

3 In 40 nawawi hadeeth what is the meaning of who innovate in our religion is going to be rejected

The clock and others" innovations adapted to the times" you mentions is something we have answers for you but let it be later so we take first things first

[Madhofd]

@TheKap1an proof of the consideration that celebrating the mawlid is a good practise. Becuz im pretty sure its a bid'ah

[brain2770]

@TheKap1an

Brother

1 how can wise people celebrate a birth date if it is not known?

2 Hamza said it is mukhtalaf ? Actually no one in the first 300yrs did it

3 It contradicts the hadeeth we only have two feasts

4 Hamza admitted it contains many wrong things and attributed the tahreem to that but that is not correct.The prophet PBUH said I did not leave any good thing (in terms of hasanat) exept I told you about. If this is hasanat then the prophet forgot it. Does he forget? The deen is complete

[Madhofd]

@TheKap1an proof plz.. thx