U.S. Constitution- the mini series; Article 1, Sections 1&2
Uploader Comments (skinnychef)
Video Responses
All Comments (22)
-
It's because our system is based in English Common Law that it's necessary to point out what is forbidden. Hence the "don't go there" amendments. (Note: not all amendments are about "what you can't do.")
Wikipedia has a decent summary on both Napoleonic Law and English Common Law. This point about permissibility is a subtle one, however, and is not expressly addressed there.
But if you do a search on "Codex Alimentarius," you will turn up an illuminating example of the difference.
-
Where do you get that idea? (citation?)
First the Constitution says what they (governments) can do and the amendments say what they cannot do, the 10th amendment says anything we haven't already said you can do, you cannot do and is reserved to the states or the people....so I'm calling bullshit.
-
Why don't you go on referendum. Isn't that the way ?!
-
If this were Napoleonic Law, it would be unconstitional, but the tradition here is English Common Law. The understanding under Napoleonic Law is that anything not expressly permitted under law is forbidden. Under English Common Law, anything not expressly forbidden is permissable.
-
hi atmore! sorry i deleted your comment b4 on accident!!!
good on you putting the pressure on culbertson! you are a great patriot!
-
Absolutely! Representative McKinney is in search of a co-sponsor for HR-1106 to do just that. I know John Culberson (the rep for my distirct in Texas) won't, but my asking him lets him know the pressures ON!!!!
Visit our discussion group on ChangeDotOrg: A More Perfect Union...I have obtained a copy of the US Constitution in Spanish, and am hoping to find someone who wants to read it, so that everyone will be able to read our constitution anywhere in the world, on their cell phones, in their own language.
vhbeazel 4 years ago
cool! i will check it out!
skinnychef 4 years ago
bewbs
azn4neoflex13 5 years ago
hahhahaa!
skinnychef 5 years ago