Carrie Underwood and Heart - Alone
Top Comments
Video Responses
All Comments (4,530)
-
@darchylde612 totally and completely agree!!!
-
It's not about Ann "owning" Carrie, or Carrie "not holding a candle to Ann." Ann Wilson is hands down the greatest female Rock vocalist to this point, and Carrie has a beautiful Country/Pop crossover voice. Two different singers coming together for one great performance.
-
I love carrie but she doesnt hold a candle to Ann Wilson. Still great vid thx.
-
Ann Wilson's voice is so powerful. Out does Carrie's by a mile!!
-
Carrie Underwood sings well but she had to step aside to let Ann hit the high note at 2:30 and her face was "shit, I wish I could do that..."
-
Definitely one of the greatest female rock vocalists of all time! Even today, she still is EXCELLENT.
-
@lasktguy Ann Wilson does very well for a 60-some y/o singer but she is not the singer she was when "Alone" first came out. But even then Charice was better due to the fact that her vocal range is greater. To put it in another way, Charice can sing Ann's songs, but Ann can't sing Charice's songs. Ann certainly belongs in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and I would not have even mentioned Charice except for Fredrock stating that Ann is the greatest female vocalist of all time.
-
@khatman100 Cherise does a good version but in no way is it as good as Ann's.
-
@TheSquidd0 I don't know why Charice and Ann Wilson singing "Alone" can't be compared. Other than the fact that Ann Wilson sings with a band and Charice uses a backing track, the lyrics are the same and if you close your eyes the sound is very close for most part.
-
@khatman100 I am a fan of Charice but you cannot compare Ann Wilson to Charice as far as Alone goes. Its a rock ballad Charice turned it into a pop standard.
all due respect to carrie underwood, but ann wilson OWNS this song, now and forevermore!
darchylde612 3 weeks ago 13
from Jose' Sepulveda, the Hermeterec......Carrie is good, but Ann Wilson is perhaps the greatest female singer in rock history. Props must go to the Legend.
Hermeterec 1 month ago 6